Blog Page 3

Forced unveilings in academic spaces worldwide are why I wear my hijab at Oxford

“If they tell me to take it off, I won’t do that, and I will leave the school because the hijab is more important to me than the school. It’s the most important thing in my life”

-Hijab-wearing schoolgirl Florinda Zeka, 2010 BBC interview about Kosovo’s hijab ban in schools.

For me, one of the most challenging aspects of wearing a veil is being at the receiving end of attempts to unveil you. I personally first encountered this at age ten, when Ofsted decided to target visibly Muslim primary school girls across the country and ask them why they wore the hijab and whether they are forced, in front of their peers. Many other visibly Muslim girls and I grew up being the target of interrogations while facing demands to condemn the two countries which imposed veiling on women. Meanwhile, we endured watching more European countries like France, Austria, Norway, Netherlands, Germany, Belgium, Kosovo, Russia (in areas like Stavropol Krai and Mordovia), Spain, Italy, and Switzerland banning the hijab and/or niqab in educational institutions. 

While our peers in these countries were fighting for their religious freedoms and right to an education, we grew up very aware of the stereotypes attached to the hijab, including being thought of as uneducated or less ambitious. We grew up being told that the hijab is a backward, alien, or unnatural practice despite the fact that women veiling is as old as civilisation itself. I cannot think of a practice that unites more women globally than veiling. From England to Assyria to Greece to India and even further afield, women have traditionally veiled for either cultural or religious reasons.

The stereotype of veiled Muslim women lacking basic skills, basic education, or being confined to their homes is the one that has had the most impact on my self-image as I began to veil. I have had to remember to stop viewing myself through a lens of ‘double-consciousness’, a sociological term meaning to constantly measure and view oneself through the prejudiced eyes, stereotypes, and contempt of the dominant culture. 

When I decided to wear the hijab in primary school, I was ridiculed and excluded by close friends. On World Book Day, for instance, I was told that I could not be Matilda, like all the other girls in my class, because “she never wears a scarf”. Gradually, I stopped many activities like drama, and felt discouraged ice skating, since I was influenced into thinking that certain activities look silly in a hijab. Giving up on hobbies however, is not much in comparison to girls who are denied an education, or offered a conditional education that compromises their religious freedoms and choice.

During my first year, when someone at the Oxford Union was speaking in an emergency debate about feminism and women’s education, I reminded him that such education does not extend to women like me in many European countries. In reply, he said: “I think it is a great privilege you have to be speaking in a place like this.” 

While the international community and women’s rights activists look the other way, veiled Muslim girls are fighting one of the hardest battles to attend school. The psychological trauma and violence of forced unveiling is a lived reality for so many veiled Muslim girls, both throughout history and across the world today. There are more countries in the world that force Muslim women to remove our veils than those that impose them, yet we grew up very aware that most people assume that we are unable to make our own choices about our own bodies and are forced. 

At a society event I attended in Oxford during my first year, someone asked me why I still wear a scarf and whether I was forced to. I told her, mindful to do so gracefully, that this is never forced. She replied: “No, you are, because if you don’t you go to hell.” I told her that Muslims do not weaponise or invoke hell upon each other and that God is the ultimate judge. She carried on following me across the room, insulting me and questioning me about Iranian law, despite me telling her that I am not only not Iranian but that there are many women in Iran who no longer veil. As expected, nobody else in the room told her to stop harassing me. 

I think about this moment most, because while today the hijab and/or niqab is banned in educational spaces across Europe, the overwhelming majority of people not only do not condemn this, but do not question it either. Only 50% of Western Europeans favour allowing Muslim women to wear religious clothing in any setting (with this still excluding face coverings), while 23% favour a ban on all religious clothing.

In UK schools, there have been many cases of both teachers and other pupils forcefully pulling Muslim girls’ hijabs. Some UK schools have also banned the hijab. Forced unveiling of any kind not only removes our identities from educational spaces and public life, but as a result of our absence, also reinforces the stereotypes of us as intellectually deficient or absent in public life and service. The most recent country to enforce forced unveilings in educational spaces is Azerbaijan, shortly after Austria and Kosovo.

However, discrimination, mockery, attempts to remove us from academic spaces, and aggressive attempts to unveil us are not recent. My Iranian great-grandmother lived under Kashf-e-Hijab (the Shah of Iran’s ban on all veils in public spaces to promote Western-style attire for both men and women). My grandmother once told me that her mother and grandmother like many women at the time would avoid going out altogether and if they had to they would go early mornings or late at night where there was less likely to be authorities on the street. If they were stopped by authorities they would say that they were tourists visiting from neighbouring Afghanistan, she said.

This forced unveiling mimicked soft power tactics to unveil Muslim women in Türkiye under the presidency of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, who viewed veiling or any traditionally Islamic clothing as backward. In his public speeches, he argued that traditional head coverings humiliated Turkish women and hindered national progress. Such beliefs and comments are not too different from verbal insults directed at veiled and visibly Muslim women today. During Kyrgyzstan’s campaign to pressure Muslim women to unveil, the government displayed billboards of women in niqabs, with the question, “My poor people, where are we going?”. In 2016, then-President Almasbek Atambayev repeatedly targeted veiled women in a press conference, also saying: “Women in mini skirts do not become suicide bombers”. 

Tunisia, for instance, like India, Belgium and other countries, no longer implements its hijab ban in academic spaces, but discrimination and ridicule directed at veiled women continues. On one occasion, Tunisian actor Mohamed Kouka publicly remarked that “the hijab makes women inferior and less worthy” and that “when I come across a veiled woman, I wish to tear the headscarf up”. Hand in hand with their fantasies to unveil us, Mohamed Kouka has also made hand gestures showing himself ripping off an imaginary hijab on air and saying that the hijab “takes the value of women to the lowest”. When later asked why he said he would rip the hijab off, Kouka said it was “a joke” and refused to apologise. 

Mimicking the harassment of women is not a “joke”, especially not to those who have experienced such physical assault. I was first threatened with this when I was in Year 8, just a little over a year after ‘Punish a Muslim Day’; a shirtless man waved his shirt at me, his upper body out of his car window, as he shouted: “I’m going to pull your hijab off.” Assault follows such threats. At age ten, my mother wrote in her diary (pictured): “Two young boys passed me, and from the back they pulled my scarf and laughed. I became very upset, but I did not turn back to look at them.” Thirty years later, when I found this page in a storage box in the garage, I asked my mother if she remembered, and she responded yes, before revealing that, even as an adult, she does not like going to funfairs because they remind her of moments like this in her childhood.

On another occasion, when I asked her whether she felt discriminated against at university for being a young mother, as I had to sometimes accompany her to university, she told me that she did not feel discriminated against or judged for that at all in front of her professors, but instead for wearing the hijab. “I always felt they look down on us, as if we are uneducated and ignorant, as if we are inferior and do not know anything.” 

We are still thought of as lacking basic skills and education. At Oxford, after I had told someone where my grandmother had studied for her master’s, they said: “Wait, what? So she’s actually smart?” In her blog, British school teacher, by the name of Miss Moga wrote of one of her experiences of working in UK schools that: “When I attended the interview I was to first have a short meeting with the headteacher to be welcomed to the school and have a little tour, the initial moment she laid her eyes on me, she looked surprised and grasped her necklace and turned to her assistant and whispered (quite loudly!), “I thought she was the most educated candidate?!”,”.

Strangers on the street have asked me, “can you speak English?” before they stop me to ask something. ‘Perhaps you could argue that they have asked in good faith’, but what about the strangers that have stopped me on the street to say “you are not welcome here”, “aren’t you hot?” and even during my year abroad, “this is Armenia, you do not need to wear your… your bandana” and “you are in Armenia, you should respect our laws”. What about strangers who threw newspapers at my cousin’s face on the tube, and received thanks from onlookers as a result? Living through this daily puts pressure on young girls growing up to unveil. As Journalist Mohamed Hassan wrote in his award-winning poem ‘The Muslim women who raised us’: “when us men hide in shirts and jeans, shaved jaws, and blue eyes, nobody asks us where we are going, why we are here, what we are trying to prove with our insistence to go to school, to get degrees…”

Forced unveiling in women’s sports is also commonplace. At a press conference, Tunisian runner Habiba Ghribi told a young hijab wearing runner to “choose between the hijab and running”, to which she later burst into tears. This also echoes France’s attitudes to hijab-wearing athletes, who are not permitted to partake in competitions unless they unveil. For myself, it was only after I came across ice skater Zahra Lari, who wears a hijab, that I started ice skating again. It reflects the profound impact that representation has, and the need for young Muslim girls to be exposed to veiled women in different roles. Forced unveiling, apart from causing great psychological distress, places a glass ceiling upon the potential and dreams of young veiled Muslim girls.

I spoke to Elif Feyza Dinc, an MPhil student reading Development Studies. She came to Oxford after graduating from Boğaziçi University, one of Türkiye’s most prestigious institutions. Though only a generation earlier, her mother “lived through every hardship that the 28 February decisions produced”. She is referring to Türkiye in 1997, when the so-called postmodern coup carried out by the secular military establishment set in motion a sweeping hijab ban across universities and public institutions. She tells me that twenty-nine years later, its effects still resonate among Muslim women in Türkiye, and in their social attitudes and sense of belonging in public space.

“The ban was enforced brutally”, and her mother was forced to leave the school where she had spent four years. She instead had to complete her education through an open high school. “The second blow,” she says, came at university gates after women wearing the hijab were barred from entering campuses and “told to remove it if they wished to receive the education they had already earned, having passed a national exam from an unequal starting point”.

Some universities set up what came to be known as Ikna odaları, or ‘persuasion rooms’, which were spaces of psychological pressure and isolation where veiled students were coerced to uncover their heads. Her mother was among those caught in the system: “She came from a small town, where people had fewer resources and fewer alternatives once these restrictions took hold. In the end, she was unable to enrol in her faculty.”

Eighteen years later, however, after the ban was lifted and after becoming a mother of three at the age of 36, Elif’s mother prepared once again for the national university entrance exam. She was admitted to the Department of History at Marmara University in Istanbul and graduated second in her cohort, yet she “still speaks of those years as the time her rights were taken from her, and of her degree as a way of fulfilling the dreams she held at 18”.

The legacy of 28 February lies not only in the coup’s decisions, but also in the everyday language now engraved in women’s social memory. Throughout our conversation, Elif had deliberately avoided the word ‘victimhood’. She told me that this is because “the language for describing the suffering imposed by a top-down secular authority has itself been shaped, and weaponised, by parts of secular society”. In Türkiye, for instance, the phrase ‘bitmedi mi mağduriyetiniz?’ (‘will your victimhood never end?’) is routinely used to silence anyone who speaks about the injustices of 28 February in public conversation. 

“To this day, Muslim women in Türkiye face ridicule in everyday life whenever they speak about the hardships they have endured because of their socio-religious identity. The ban may have been lifted, but the right to name what happened is still contested,” Elif says.

As we study in Oxford, and as you read, young Muslim Azerbaijani schoolgirls are having school gates closed on them and are sitting on the school steps studying in isolation. The international community of women’s rights activists have failed to protect them and stand up for their right to an education. Malala Yousafzai is among Oxford’s most well-known alumni and has built her entire brand of activism around young girls’ access to an education, but her silence in recent weeks proves that advocacy for women’s rights, including the right to an education and a right over our bodies, does not extend to veiled Muslim girls across the world, and most recently, distressed Azerbaijani schoolgirls.

When I reported on Oxford’s scholarship for Afghan women, who have been denied an education since the Taliban returned to power, it was painful to know that Oxford has not set up a similar programme for Azerbaijani girls. One could be quick to tell me that perhaps they are considering it and that these things take time and planning. But on the contrary, out of 193 UN recognised countries, Iran is the only one that has not hesitated to offer Azerbaijani girls a sanctuary and access to the education that they are being denied in their own country. 

I ask all readers to reflect on what it means to deny a veiled girl an education, how little care one must have for that girl’s progress, place in society and livelihood. How these laws serve to further perpetuate the stereotypes of being uneducated, not thinking for ourselves when we veil, or being silent and absent. 

As school gates slam in the face of young veiled girls and veiled teachers are being dismissed from their jobs when these bans are implemented, I ask all to reflect on the danger that not having a veiled teacher can have on pupils; when they are not taught or learning from a veiled woman. When the educated person standing in front of them in the classroom is never a veiled woman. 

Even in countries where the hijab is not formally banned, women are discriminated against into unveiling.  US school teacher Hind Haddad wrote of her experience of her first day at work: “When I arrived, the principal saw me and immediately frowned once she saw my appearance and the hijab on my head. She then informed me that it would be my first and last day at the school before I left to go to my classroom”.  British schoolteacher, Miss Moga also says students looked at her “like I was some kind of alien or make-believe creature and I was instantly bombarded with questions such as: “Why do you dress like that?” and “Are you hot under there?”,” On another occasion, when a senior member of staff witnessed the Islamaphobic comments she was receiving from students, she told her, ”I can understand why they do not respect you” and, “the way you are dressed is hindering their learning.” 

I reflect on my own experience as a veiled student in Oxford. As a fresher, I was hyper-conscious to not make mistakes in front of my peers or ask obvious questions during lectures because I knew that any scrutiny, especially with regard to intelligence or competence, would not just be directed at me as an individual, but would extend to people’s image of visibly Muslim women. When I expressed my exhaustion and frustration at this to someone during first year, they justified the prejudice. They said that I cannot expect anyone to consider me intelligent regardless of whether I have made it to the same competitive university as them or sitting in the same lecture hall as them, “because so long as you continue to wear the hijab, people will think that you lack critical thinking”.

Despite such force, pressure, and effort to unveil us, especially in academic spaces, our hijab will always be a reminder that Muslim women not only belong but thrive in these spaces. We have much more stamina and strength than to remove our veils in the face of soft power tactics, pervasive stereotypes, or even such bans and hard power tactics to eradicate our hijab. We are fully aware that our presence and veil irritate many who cannot stand to see us progress, but they will never make us compromise on our values, chip away at our identity, nor separate this hijab from our education. The two go hand in hand. Indeed, the world’s oldest university, two centuries older than Oxford, was founded by none other than a Muslim woman: Fatima al-Fihriya.

I wear my hijab in Oxford because girls younger than me across the world are denied an education because of this; my hijab is my way of resisting, of asserting our identity in an environment where our presence is unjustly limited. And because, as one social media user put it: “Those who fear a little girl’s headscarf also fear her pen.”

Oriel Provost and Proctors confirm that Cofnas event will go ahead at Extraordinary SU meeting

Lord Mendoza, Provost of Oriel College, confirmed that Nathan Cofnas’ event at Oriel will go ahead at today’s Extraordinary SU Conference of Common Rooms (CCR). 

At the meeting, JCR and MCR representatives questioned Mendoza, alongside the Proctors’ Office Clerk Gillain Hamnett and the University of Oxford’s Chief Diversity Officer Tim Soutphommasane. Speaking on Oriel’s involvement in the event, Mendoza stated: “we want to live up to our statutory duty to protect free speech – free speech for the event and those to protest it.”

Mendoza also confirmed that the location of the event in Oriel has been changed to protect students. 

Representatives from JCRs and MCRs as well as the SU representatives also debated a motion proposed by St Catherine’s College’s MCR president Xiangyue Wang, entitled: “No Hate Speech at Oxford”. 

The proposed motion calls for a statement to be issued by the SU, pending voting from college representatives which is due to end tomorrow.

Further proposals include mandating the SU to spend £1,000 on diversity initiatives this term, for SU officers to ask the University’s proctors to attend the event in case of speech violating the 2010 Equality Act, and to support an independent review of the risk assessment and approval process for the event. 

In the Q&A, students raised concerns that the content of Cofnas’s talk would not be lawful and could amount to harassment. The Ghent University academic is controversial for his role in publicising plagiarism allegations into Professor Jason Arday this July. Arday, who denied these allegations, resigned from Cambridge following media scrutiny and was later found dead. 

The proposed motion notes that Nathan Cofnas is a self-described “race realist” who has previously said that without DEI (Diversity Equity and Inclusion), the number of black professors at Harvard would “approach 0%”. 

One student asked whether the University considered race science and Eugenics an incitement to racial hatred. Soutphommasane responded by highlighting the University’s need to take students “in good faith” regarding the content of the events they plan to hold. Cofnas’s talk is publicised as a talk on whether DEI is “undermining higher education”. 

Soutphommasane said: “I can tell you, as Chief Diversity Officer, these are questions I deal with every day. Having a debate with DEI is something that is not off limits for debate. I have to engage in these debates every day as a part of my job.”

A representative from St Antony’s College responded saying “it seems disingenuous to give [the speaker] the most generous benefit of the doubt given the broad range of things that could be said under the title [of the debate].”

Mendoza acknowledged the public outcry to cancel the event from students and staff across Oxford, saying “we don’t particularly want what, at best you might call a ‘controversial lecture’ But free speech guidance is clear. However enraged you might feel, however much you might feel something will damage the reputation of the institution.” He confirmed that the College has consulted lawyers who unanimously maintain that “the event must go ahead”. 

The speakers continually highlighted the duties placed on the University by the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023. Following the implementation of the Act last year, both the University and Oriel have updated their Codes of Practice on freedom of speech to reflect the stronger legislative duty to protect lawful speech.

Under the Act, Universities and their constituent institutions, such as Oxford colleges, can be reported to a new Office for Students complaints scheme if they fail to protect the freedom of speech rights of visiting speakers and staff. The complaints scheme has the power to issue fines and mandate compensation to those affected. 

Oriel’s new Code states that freedom of speech must be “robustly protected” and that cancellation of events is “undesirable and should be exceptional”. The code accepts that this means students will be “confronted with views that some find shocking, disturbing or offensive”. Mendoza also said that the code will likely be reviewed after the event, but that the policy is  unlikely to change. 

“This is a very serious moment for Oxford and its colleges,” Mendoza said. “This is not something we looked to take on, but we are fulfilling our duty. We are pleased to be an organisation that wants to protect freedom of speech.” He also noted Oriel’s strong support for DEI initiatives and its outreach work. 

Hamnett confirmed that the Proctors are conducting an ongoing risk assessment to ensure the safety of students at the event. She said that society events are not approved in advance by Proctors and can only be cancelled by them pending a risk assessment assessing  whether it is “safe and lawful”. 

A representative from Nuffield College asked how the event could be approved if the assessment is still live. Hamnett said that the current situation is ongoing and “dynamic”, reassuring that there will be a cut-off period but “the decision, at the moment, is that nothing has come to light that would mean the event would be cancelled”.

St Catz MCR’s proposed No Hate Speech motion calls for the presence of the University’s Proctors or another independent supervisor at the event to monitor the event for speech potentially violating the 2010 Equality Act. Hamnett confirmed that the Proctor’s security officers, commonly referred to as “bulldogs”, would be at the event.

The CCR President, Roxana Rusu, explained that involving an independent body to supervise is “really crucial” and “something that we are really pushing for”. 

Student representatives raised concerns about the Proctors’ role in the event, with one stating that “mitigations don’t make an event safe” and it is “disingenuous to say that this event is safe because the proctors are getting involved”.

Rusu explained that the Extraordinary CCR was called to ensure that measures decided at the meeting could be implemented as quickly as possible. “While we can only work with the structures we have previously,” she said “we really want to change them for the future, for the better”. 

Oxford’s Reform society has previously defended the invitation on social media, noting: “since we are a student society registered with Oxford University, constituent colleges of the University are under a legal obligation to host events like ours by virtue of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023”. The statement goes on to say “Reform society is committed to hosting Nathan Cofnas, and allowing attendees at the event to engage in respectful dialogue with the same.”

The Free Speech Union has encouraged members to send emails congratulating Mendoza and Oriel for “standing firm” and for its “excellent” code of practice on free speech. 

Common Room Presidents will be voting on the motion in the next 24 hours. If the motion is passed, a statement is expected to be issued tomorrow.

The Oxford students Britain turned away

When you matriculate at Oxford University, the Vice-Chancellor asks that the attending students be accepted. Under Christopher Wren’s painted ceiling, after copious submissions, emails, and acceptances, the University still has one fleeting chance to turn around and say ‘no’. 

There is a sense of reward in this ritual. As the Vice-Chancellor herself says in the ceremony: “It is not easy to earn a place at Oxford – we are the number one University in the world, after all.” While many students recognise the role of luck in getting to this moment, few are aware of just how lucky they are. 

Over the past seven months, some of Oxford’s offer holders have been hoping for their luck to change. They met the academic requirements and demonstrated sufficient intellectual rigour. What led them to fail the test was, instead, the passports they held. 

They are the victims of a visa brake introduced by the Home Office, which blocks students from Afghanistan, Myanmar, Sudan, and Cameroon from obtaining UK visas. Caught in the politics of immigration enforcement, these students felt the elation of an Oxford offer, followed by the cruelty of being told “no”.  

Seven months on, some still hold out hope of making it to Oxford. 

The visa brake was part of a wide-ranging immigration reform package that has driven anger at the Home Secretary in the Labour government. To justify the claims, Mahmood cited a 470% increase in those on student visas from the four countries claiming asylum. 

Over the phone, Yama jests that, as a scientist, he can recognise “when evidence is selectively deployed”. He is an Afghan British researcher who has worked at the Oxford Vaccine Group since 2013, and he believes that the countries were chosen for political reasons. “They are not a priority for our politicians,” he scoffs. Their lack of representation means those in power question, “‘Is it really worth fighting for?’ Morally, absolutely. But economically or publicity-wise, ‘it’s just 10 students’”.

Earlier this year, Yama wrote to then-Prime Minister Keir Starmer, met with MPs, and has led a UK parliamentary petition against the brake signed by nearly 40,000 people. He hopes that “next time someone thinks about Sudanese or Afghans or whatever other country,” this campaign would mean that  “they might spend one minute to pause and say, ‘I’m going to do this, and this is very unfair’”.

Filings from a court case challenging the policy serve Yama’s point. The Home Office’s own metric for the visa brake shows that, were all countries being treated equally, other countries, including Bangladesh, would have been included in the brake. The country was excluded, not because of its role in visa abuse, but because of deeper bilateral ties, such that “any action on Bangladesh would likely incur a far more pronounced impact upon relations”.

Ask any of the Oxford offer holders what they hoped to achieve with a British education, and they do not ask for asylum. When a coup in Myanmar turned into civil war, Eaint watched her home country fall apart from her student accommodation at King’s College London. Even knowing that, at home, conflict had “erased life as people knew it”, she never considered asylum. “For asylum to be framed as the easy way out,” she says, “is a very disingenuous justification”. She had an offer to begin a Master’s in Health Service Improvement and Evaluation in Oxford this October. 

Studying abroad is not just about attending a particular university. For affected students, it is one of the few ladders out of the devastation caused by decades of civil unrest. Afghanistan has not recovered from the Soviet invasion in 1979 and, since the Taliban returned to power, women and girls have been systematically excluded from education past primary school. For them, universities abroad can represent one of the few remaining routes to continue their education.  

Education is foundational to recovery. Alongside her studies, Aisha has piloted an e-learning programme providing university-level education to women in six Afghan provinces. “It is a process that needs building, but we should not be waiting for the moment the Taliban are no longer in power to start working on the workforce.” She had hoped to use her time in Britain to expand the programme through the University’s networks.

Back in Oxford, Yama runs a similar programme offering education for Afghan women and girls; he’s seen the impact of education through his sister, now a doctor in Denmark. Had his father not been so desperate for her to get an education, fleeing the Taliban in the process, “we would have a woman with no knowledge. We would have one less doctor.”

Eaint’s grief is twofold: the visa brake does not just represent the loss of her own offer, but the knowledge of “what doors this was closing for people who just wanted a better future and education”. “I had already gotten a bachelor’s degree in the UK,” she says. “I was so acutely aware that studying in the UK had changed my life in every sense possible.” 

Taking away the opportunity is equally life changing. One Afghan student told Yama:  “What I’m going to do is this: I’m going to go into those boats. I’m going to cross the channel. I’m going to come into this country, and I am going to study. Because I already have an offer. I have done everything in the past four or five years to qualify and get a scholarship from the UK, and now I’m being stopped not because I don’t meet their standard, but because I’m Afghan.” When Yama tried to dissuade the student, he was reminded that “you are in Oxford. That’s why you are saying, and you are advising me, ‘don’t do that’. Please, before going to sleep tonight, spend ten minutes putting yourself in my place and think about what you would have done.” They have not been in contact since. 

Underpinning the Home Office’s policy is a sense of why international students come to Britain. But these students saw their Oxford offers not as a way out, but as an opportunity to help their home countries. They are the students who fell through the cracks created by a blanket ban. 

Ibrahim was on a rare break from his internship when we called. For the first few minutes of the call, he recounts in detail the potential changes to Sudan’s health referral system he has identified. Working in hospitals in Sudan during the ongoing war, he witnesses daily the challenges of a health system under stress – just three months into his placement, the hospital he worked at was filled with victims of a drone strike in a nearby town.  “There was just so much pressure to take care of all these patients,” he says. Still, you have to be “vigilant”  to survive in an active war zone. At Oxford, Ibrahim wanted to focus on how to implement his changes in a “volatile” environment as part of his Master’s in Health Service Improvement and Evaluation.

Eaint calls from the Thailand-Myanmar border, where she is working on a project helping those fleeing her native Myanmar with medical and humanitarian aid. Ironically, she laughs, the project is funded by an Oxford research institute. 

For everyone, the Oxford offer symbolised that people cared. Ibrahim recalls coworkers and friends asking him why he was smiling so much after receiving his offer. To him, it validated that he had “ the potential to contribute” to the field. Having spent her interview talking about their plans to improve the health system back home, Eaint tells us her offer “felt like a validation of the fact that these issues mattered”. Safar, an Afghan student due to study an MPhil in Development Studies, told us that his offer “represented a possibility: the belief that, if people with the fewest resources are given an opportunity, they can become catalysts for change within societies that have endured decades of war and violence.”

What does it mean, then, that these offers are taken away? Yama describes himself as proudly Afghan British; he was a key part of the team that led the development of the Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID vaccine and is currently working on the world’s first Ebola vaccine. His expertise means he could easily move to the US, should he choose, but he wants to stay: “This country has given me another home.” The current policy, he says, “is against British values”. 

For Safar, the policy has shaken his faith in what Britain and Europe stand for. Having faced discrimination growing up as a refugee in Pakistan, he always thought that “progressive” Europe was different. “One of the reasons I had always wanted to study in Europe was my belief that Europe was built on the idea of human equality. I never imagined that I would encounter discrimination embedded in government policy in a liberal, so-called first-world country.”

The Home Office itself recognised the dangers of the blanket ban – officials considered targeted interventions, including by course. Their own analysis noted that “the blanket ‘brake’ model offered speed and simplicity but raised proportionality and litigation risks”. The office intends the measure to be temporary and precede more “nuanced” interventions targeting the root of abuse. 

What the Home Office failed to consider was the human cost. By implementing the brake in March, when most offers for UK universities come out, many students felt both the elation of Oxford saying “yes”, before the “numbness” of it being taken away.  Having gone through the rigorous application process, Ibrahim assumed he would be exempt when he first heard of the brake. 

The Home Office did not respond to Cherwell’s request for comment. 

As the case has developed, Oxford has issued many statements. Each notes that the University receives “a significant number of applications from talented students affected by war and persecution” and reaffirms the University’s commitment as a University of Sanctuary. A blanket script is the only way to answer a blanket policy – this national policy effectively ties the University’s hands from abiding by its promise to students.

Students, like Ibrahim or Eaint, who had the UK as their only option for 2026-2027 study were left with no options. If they were to look abroad, as many are now doing, they would have to sit out a whole academic year. 

Oxford has stated that it had “offered the same options to the same offer holders”. Whatever the University has offered, the consequences for students are scattered. For some students, holding out hope is painful and unrealistic. The blanket change resulted from the efforts of students, like Ibrahim, to fight for their offers. 

Though these students are not in the Sheldonian Theatre, they are waiting one last time to see whether the answer to their place at Oxford might be “no”. This summer they launched a legal challenge to the visa brake. While the initial case failed at the High Court this summer, Cherwell can confirm that they have applied for permission to appeal.

Hope remains for those who have not withdrawn their applications. Students with unconditional offers, including Ibrahim, have been given the chance to defer to allow for the result of appeal. Even for the Afghans we spoke to who lost their offers, Yama is optimistic that the overturning of the brake would allow them to say “This student was successfully selected for last semester, but they couldn’t get a visa. Could we renegotiate their position for next year?”

Should the appeal fail, the Home Secretary also retains the power to grant entry clearance to students outside immigration rules – the circumstances in which she would do so “are likely to be rare, and will be informed by the nature and purpose of the Student Visa Brake”. To be an exception to a government immigration policy might be rare, but to get into Oxford has always involved some degree of luck and a willingness to test the odds. 

Reflecting on the fact his future rests with a British judge, Ibrahim takes “satisfaction” from “deciding to persevere” till the very end. It has, he admits, been “a very long and very exhausting process”, but the thought of making it to Oxford still excites him. “I think Oxford is worth it. I think it’s really worth the wait. I hope it’s a wait.”

Allow term to change you

0

It is well known that pride comes before a fall – an excessive assurance in one’s own invulnerability is a likely recipe for disaster. At university, however, an impenetrable facade and a certain self-conviction appear to have become the norm. My issue with this culture is how rarely – if ever – I hear about a desire to improve our skills. It often feels as if the term becomes about what one can prove, with social currency often being earned in the process.

The drama scene at Oxford frequently epitomises how student output can become more about personalities than prioritising the art itself. The Oxford University Dramatic Society (OUDS) venerates certain student actors, often drooling over the idea of a student elite. The most recent Playhouse production went so far as to proclaim its own project to be the “height of student drama”, while another recent play even featured a rotation of chosen students acting on different nights, presumably intended to have the feel of ‘celebrity-guest’ appearances.

The BNOC list produces another obvious example of this obsession with student reputation. Sure, revealing the campus’ popular names is just some light entertainment. But there is a danger in viewing students as “Oxford’s most famous – and infamous – characters”. This preoccupation sets a precedent that students are not in a process of growth, but rather formed figures to be put on a pedestal.

This unnerving attitude of projection over progress produces more smoke than there is fire; it becomes more about the ‘who’ than the ‘what’. The opportunities term holds appear to be approached by many with self-promotion or social kudos in mind; to my mind, they lack earnest desire to develop a passion. Students often act as if they and their peers are final products, as if we’re professionals already – we’re not. In the racket of this desire to prove ourselves, self-reflection appears to be a lost concept.

Our academic studies require a willingness to change – without humility, we would consistently be chained to our old methods and opinions, and would never grow. You would look ridiculous walking into a tutorial trying to prove yourself, rather than submit to being broken down and remoulded. Yet, look for this attitude outside the vulnerable confines of the tutorial room, and you will find that Oxford culture lacks this genuineness.

Stubbornness also shows up in the chaos of student life. Oxford is rife with poor management and even self-deprecation; admissions of poorly written essays or various social regrets echo around daily. The assumption that students here are put together is wildly incorrect. But amongst missed deadlines, cancelled plans, and failed projects (which are often a product of an admirable ambition to do anything and everything), a genuine desire to learn and improve from experience is rarely talked about – at least not publicly. It is acceptable to be in an ‘essay crisis’, or to not care about making your 9.00am lecture (or any other plan, for that matter), yet a sincere want to change habits or fix your failings is looked down upon; transparency is a weakness. 

It’s important to clarify that I am in no way taking issue with excellence. High standards are ideal, and Oxford consistently witnesses excellent student work that should absolutely be acknowledged. I’m also not saying that we shouldn’t have self-conviction and be aware of our talents – my issue is not with confidence, nor is it with skill-based hierarchy. It’s the lack of servitude. There’s a profound difference between timidity and humility that Oxford students appear to be unaware of. There is an immense grace in possessing talent (and knowing it) and still constantly submitting yourself to being changed and reformed for the better. Skill and personality should not be about reputation and popularity, but about using skill for greater purpose. Fostering natural talent in this way is an ultimate form of self-respect.

A genuine desire to constantly reshape and reform what you pursue will take you far. Treating term time like a showcase for your facade of impartiality or self-assuredness in the hopes of external validation has made Oxford’s student culture about protecting and perpetuating one’s image – throughout the spectrum of students parading their skill to apologising for a lack of it, it appears to be devoid of genuine humility and desire to improve. Passion has been confused (or at least overshadowed by) prestige, and a desire to serve true purpose and apply oneself seems rare. Why can’t we transfer the humility needed in the tutorial room to all aspects of our time here, whether socially, artistically, or practically?  

Ultimately, if student culture continues to work against the virtue of self-improvement, and we carry on being quite so unapologetic, the fall from pride may not be public, but will be a personal one – the loss of the most developed version of yourself. Immense strength can be found in allowing the term to change you, no matter how weak this is made out to be.

Burning the candle at both ends: Diwali in Oxford

0

Oxford has a curious relationship with time. We do not so much live through autumn as progress through Michaelmas, dividing our lives into eight neatly numbered weeks. Ask a student the date, and you may get a blank look. Ask what week it is and the answer comes instantly, usually with a sigh.

Somewhere among the tutorials, the essay deadlines and the increasingly frantic conversations about fifth week, Diwali arrives. This year it falls on Sunday 8th November, the very first day of fifth week. The festival of lights is entirely indifferent to the university calendar. It does not know that an essay is due on Friday. It simply turns up, as it always has, and asks to be celebrated.

Diwali had been looming in my calendar for weeks, heralded by a formal hall whose menu did the festival few favours. Even so, it has managed to creep up on me, and I am yet to buy a single card or box of sweets. Oxford time, it seems, runs rather faster than the lunar kind.

Spend long enough here, and the eight-week term stops feeling like an administrative convenience and starts to feel like the natural unit of existence. We talk about time as though it were a countdown: “It’s already fourth week”, “I’ll deal with that after sixth”, “I can’t believe we’re halfway through”. Each phrase measures life by how much of the term has been spent and how much remains. There is something charming about this private language, but also something faintly alarming. The Oxford calendar becomes so dominant that everything else must be fitted around it. Birthdays, visits home, and religious festivals become things to be accommodated, slotted between a tutorial and a deadline or postponed until ninth week.

The point is not that Oxford prevents anyone from celebrating Diwali. Nobody is forbidden from lighting a diya – fire regulations permitting. It is that Oxford shapes how we think about the time available for celebration. The term does not tell us what to value. It simply makes sure we are always counting. Diwali demarcates a different kind of time. Its date moves with the lunar calendar, landing anywhere between the middle of October and the middle of November, but its substance barely moves at all. It has been celebrated across generations and continents, through migration and through the ordinary upheavals of family life, and it asks for many of the same things each year: lamps lit at dusk, the house made ready, sweets shared, and family gathered. Where Oxford is preoccupied with moving forward, Diwali is built on return. Part of its meaning lies in the fact that you have done this before, and that others did it before you.

I inherited Diwali from my nani. For as long as I can remember, it has been the thing that draws our family together. My dad is English, and he has never once treated it as someone else’s festival. He has thrown himself into it so wholeheartedly that it now belongs to all of us, and we all love it. This points to a quiet paradox. We tend to treat repetition as the opposite of progress, the thing you do once you have stopped improving. Yet traditions draw much of their meaning from being repeated. A ritual performed once is a novelty. Performed for a lifetime, it becomes a way of belonging.

Oxford continually urges us to advance: to read more, achieve more, and move on to the next deadline. Diwali suggests that coming back to something familiar can matter just as much. Why, then, can a festival like Diwali feel like an interruption to university life rather than part of it?

It would be rather unfair to accuse Oxford of being hostile to tradition. Few places are quite so enthusiastic about preserving it. This is a university where students sit exams in gowns and carnations, where grace is said in Latin before dinner, and where a college’s age is a matter of competitive pride. Tradition is not merely tolerated here. It is the house style.

Yet there is a telling difference between the traditions built into the institution’s routine and those students must make room for themselves. Formal hall is on the timetable. Matriculation has its own day. Christmas falls conveniently during the vacation, so nobody has to ask for an extension because of it. Diwali, by contrast, is something you fit in: a society dinner, a puja between essays, a call home squeezed in before the library.

At Oxford, Diwali often feels makeshift. Last year a few of us held a puja on our staircase, with candles and a handful of murtis, small statues of the deities, balanced on cardboard boxes. It did not go especially smoothly, and it was over almost as soon as it began. But we had made the time to celebrate, and that, more than anything, was what gave it meaning.

None of this requires anyone to have been deliberately exclusive. Institutions tend to remember what they were built to remember. The question, perhaps, is not whether Oxford makes time for tradition, but which traditions have the privilege of being considered part of ordinary life. This is not an argument for abolishing the term, or for telling everyone simply to slow down. Oxford’s eight weeks are useful. They concentrate effort, give shape to an otherwise shapeless amount of work, and end, mercifully, on a fixed date. But they are also an artificial structure, and life carries on beyond their boundaries. 

Diwali is a reminder that not everything important can be measured in deadlines, achievements or weeks remaining. Some things are measured instead in years of return: the same lamps, the same food, the same people, one autumn after another. Perhaps the strange thing about celebrating Diwali at Oxford is not that an ancient festival must find its place within an eight-week term. It is that we have grown so used to the eight-week term that we forget how arbitrary its boundaries really are. Diwali does not interrupt Oxford time. It reminds us that there are other ways of keeping it.

Cowley cinema nominated for top award amidst campaign for survival against Oriel

The Ultimate Picture Palace (UPP), Oxford’s only independent cinema, has been shortlisted for Cinema of the Year at the British Independent Film Awards (BIFA). 

The cinema on Cowley Road is one of five contending cinemas. It is currently in the midst of a battle with its landlord, Oriel College, to secure its tenancy.

In reaction to being shortlisted, the UPP told Cherwell: “We’re absolutely delighted. To make the final five, from more than 70 cinemas across the UK, is a huge achievement. We’d like to thank everyone who nominated us, who visits the cinema and has supported our campaign to protect its future.

“The UPP exists because of the people who care about it. We’re community-owned, supported by more than 1,200 shareholders made up of locals and film lovers, and everything we do is driven by a belief that independent cinemas matter and that community matters.”

The BIFA’s Cinema of the Year award is the only award celebrating  UK cinemas at the heart of their communities. The award is decided by a public vote of 50,000, which decides the shortlist and nominees alongside a jury of industry professionals. Other finalists this year are Abbeygate Cinema in Suffolk, Campus West in Hertfordshire, Hippodrome Cinema in Scotland, and The Kinema in the Woods in Lincolnshire. 

Open seven days a week in an Art Deco single-screen auditorium, the UPP screens a mix of foreign-language and classic films. With nearby suppliers like Missing Bean and G&D’s Cafe, it offers locally-sourced drinks and snacks before the film.

One voter featured on BIFA’s website said:  “I’d gone on my own, but the UPP has such a strong sense of community that I felt like I was in a room full of friends.” The UPP collaborates with student initiatives like the Oxford University Filmmaking Foundation and aims to connect individuals and communities through social inclusion.

After its last owner, Becky Hallsmith, passed away in 2018, the UPP became community-owned through a fundraising initiative. Their screening of Hamnet with Dame Pippa Harris, the film’s Golden Globe-winning producer, BAFTA CEO, and longtime fan of the cinema, helped the UPP gain attention. 

The building needs repairs, which investors refuse to fund because of the current lease’s 2037 expiry date. It would need a lease of at least 20 to 25 years to secure funding. In 2025, a National Lottery grant was withheld from the UPP as it did not meet the lease conditions. The UPP have said that Oriel “won’t commit because our building is in the footprint of their plans for a ‘Fifth Quad’ to accommodate graduate students”.

Concerning the current status of their campaign to secure their future, the UPP told Cherwell: “Our landlord, Oriel College, has so far been unwilling to commit to the long-term future we need. However, we’re currently in positive discussions with Oriel about a way forward, and we’re hopeful that we can reach an agreement that allows the UPP to stay in its historic home.

“Our Save the UPP posters seem to be in every other window on some streets around Cowley Road and East Oxford. Being shortlisted for this award just shows how much the cinema is valued, and we hope it will help reinforce the case for protecting the UPP.”

Oriel did not comment on the impact that this award could have on their negotiations; it told Cherwell: “The Ultimate Picture Palace is one of the country’s historic cinemas. We are very proud that it has been shortlisted for the BIFA Cinema of the Year award.”

One of last year’s entrants for Cinema of the Year said that they saw a 20% increase in ticket sales after their BIFA nomination. BIFA notes that “votes are weighted taking into account the footfall through your cinema over the course of the preceding year”. With a petition of over 24,430 verified signatures to save their cinema, the UPP say it is an exciting time for them. 

The UPP told Cherwell: “We’d love to bring the Cinema of the Year award back to Oxford when the winner is announced on December 6th.”

Forty-nine Oriel SCR members condemn Nathan Cofnas’ views in statement

0

Members of Oriel College’s Senior Common Room (SCR) have described Nathan Cofnas’ claims about race and intelligence as “racist, abhorrent and without scientific foundation”, a week before he is due to speak at the college. 

In a statement signed “in a personal capacity”, 49 fellows and members of Oriel’s SCR said they do not support Cofnas’ views. The statement said his claims are “fundamentally at odds with the values of equality, dignity and respect” that should define the “academic community”. 

Cofnas, a self-described “race realist”, is due to speak at Oriel’s Harris Lecture Theatre on 17th November. The event, titled “An Evening with Nathan Cofnas: Is DEI Undermining Higher Education?”, is organised by the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS). 

Cofnas, a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University, was previously dismissed by Emmanuel College, Cambridge, after writing a blog post claiming that the number of Black academics would “approach zero” under a meritocracy. Cambridge’s internal investigation later found that his comments did not constitute discrimination or harassment. 

In July, Cofnas published a Substack post accusing Jason Arday of plagiarising his doctoral thesis. Arday, who denied plagiarising, resigned from Cambridge after weeks of media scrutiny and was found dead on 14th August. Liverpool John Moores University, which awarded the doctorate, concluded Arday’s doctorate should stand. 

The signed statement rejects “the suggestion that Black people owe their place in universities and public life to anything other than their abilities” and says that the event “has caused great distress among students, staff and colleagues, and in particular among members of our Black community”. The statement also adds that Cofnas’ invitation “undermines and distracts from the many positive actions the College has taken in recent years to support greater diversity, equity and inclusion, which have greatly enriched College life”.

The statement reads: “Freedom of speech is not freedom for ideas or opinions to go unchallenged by evidence, questioning and argument.” 

The signatories stressed that the statement “does not represent the position of the College” and that they “respect its [Oriel’s] position of not commenting on the views of speakers at meetings held in the college”. They added that “there are many reasons why others in the Senior Common Room may be unable to sign this statement”.

Cofnas’ invitation has prompted widespread opposition across Oxford. An open letter initiated by Oxford Students’ Coalition Against Racism has been signed by nearly 30,000 people at the time of publication, and Oxfordshire Stand Up To Racism is planning a protest in Oriel Square at 5pm on 17th November, an hour before Cofnas’ scheduled event. 

The Oxford SU has also called an extraordinary meeting of the Conference of Common Rooms on 11th November to discuss the motion ‘No Hate Speech At Oxford’. Oriel MCR was one of the five common rooms that requested the meeting. If passed, the motion calls for the SU to spend £1,000 on a diversity initiative and issue a statement about the Cofnas event.

In a statement on 3rd November, the University’s Chief Diversity Officer, Tim Soutphommasane, acknowledged receiving “concerns about racism, and the safety and welfare of Black and ethnic minority students and staff” from a “significant number of students and staff”. However, he reaffirmed the University’s legal duty to “promote and secure freedom of speech” and did not call for the event’s cancellation. 

A spokesperson for Oriel told Cherwell: “Oriel College is committed to upholding freedom of speech within the law and has a statutory duty to do so. This includes the freedom to express views that many find deeply offensive.

“We are also committed to promoting inclusion and maintaining an environment that is free from all forms of discrimination and harassment, including racial discrimination.” 

The spokesperson added that it is Oriel’s policy to permit events booked by students who are committee members of registered societies, but that permission “does not imply endorsement”. The college also referred to its Bullying and Harassment Policy and Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion Policy. 

OURS has also said that Oriel is legally obliged to host Cofnas “by virtue of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023”. Guidance published alongside the act states that universities and constituent institutions – such as Oxford colleges – must maintain a “very strong presumption in favour of admitting lawful speech”.

Others have also defended Cofnas’ right to speak. For example, the Free Speech Union’s website includes a template email congratulating Oriel for “standing firm” and holding the event. 

OURS was contacted for comment.

No, I won’t buy a scholar’s gown

0

On the day I arrived in Oxford, my college mother gave me one piece of advice: “Oh, don’t worry, Prelims don’t matter at all”. Of course, on paper, she was right: for most students at Oxford (provided you pass), Prelims or Mods don’t affect your degree classification nor what you can pick in second year. In theory, for the humanities, they are a chance to practise the art of essay writing under time pressure. But, as an ancient academic institution, Oxford risks forcing division between students by encouraging rivalry between the best of the best. Thus is the philosophy behind the scholar’s gown: a “black gown of Russell cord or synthetic material in full style with a gathered stiffened yoke behind and short open sleeves” (according to the University guide to academic dress), bulkier than the modest commoner’s gown, and given to those who achieve a distinction in their first set of Oxford examinations.

I am no scholar. I made the humble mistake of merely passing my Prelims. It therefore came as a surprise when I received an email saying that I’d been given an exhibition – an award given by certain colleges for reasons ranging from good Collections results to simply being in the favour of your tutors (which one I fall into remains, as yet, a mystery). Both awards entitle recipients at my college to wear the scholar’s gown as part of our sub fusc, alongside a host of other rewards that vary between colleges. Yet I refuse to subscribe to this privileged and elitist attitude towards academic achievement.

All of us worked hard to get into this university: we endured months of prep for the personal statement, put together written work, and faced the intensity of the interview season. Behind that are good GCSE results and likely years of seeking academic validation from teachers. Every person at this university deserves their place; we do not need to prove ourselves further. Some, naturally, work harder than others, and that is reflected in the variety of degree classifications handed out alongside academic prizes. But we must remember that academic reward is not the end goal, and that Prelims are just that: preliminary examinations. When simply settling into the rhythm and social circles of university life is hard enough in first year, must we pile on the pressure even further?

I do not, and cannot, consider myself above my academic peers. Neither the English cohort at my college, all of whom worked hard during exam season and both struggled and shone throughout the year, nor anyone else in other faculties, where marking criteria and the number of Distinctions handed out vary massively. So why would I draw attention to this with a billowing gown? During Finals, as you gaze around the marquee full of hundreds of students in sub fusc, I imagine the last thing you want to be fearing is your own academic inferiority.

The way some colleges reward scholars seems disproportionate to how most are won. At my own, St Hugh’s, I have been invited to “make a short Declaration” at the Governing Body meeting, as well as to attend a free formal and drinks reception with my tutors. All for only one week’s worth of exams! I am only thankful that, unlike central colleges, gowns are discouraged at our formal halls, so there is no obligation to parade around your luck in first-year exams for the next few years. The scholar’s gown is an overt sign of academic comparison, fostering jealousy and rivalry between friends and coursemates – it has no place in what should be friendly, encouraging communities.

Another major issue is the disparity between scholarships across courses and colleges. This is apparent in the criteria for a Distinction: in English and History, candidates must achieve an average mark of 67 with two papers above 70. In Modern Languages, an average of 70 is required, although History and Modern Languages need one mark above 70 and no mark below 64. The boundaries for the sciences are far more vague, since marks are scaled depending on the difficulty of each paper.  Meanwhile, in Medicine, tutors at each college decide scholarships. The prevalence of certain subjects amongst lists of scholars speaks to an inconsistent approach to Distinctions, and so it is hardly fair for their reward to have such a large financial and material benefit for students.

Between colleges, there are all sorts of discrepancies: Pembroke displays a list of scholars and exhibitioners near the porters’ lodge whilst subtracting £1000 from scholars’ battels and inviting them to a scholars’ lecture and dinner. At St Hugh’s, the sum is £300 a year for the rest of their course, whilst at Somerville it is £500 and at Hertford it is £250. Such large monetary gifts as incentives for good academic performance are surprising but also out of proportion. My tutors informed me in Freshers’ week that they valued the growth of my academic voice and development through tutorial essays far more than exam performance, yet the rewards for the latter speak volumes as to what the University values: prestige for the institution.

Of course, it is important to recognise and celebrate academic achievement, and this article ignores the not inconsiderable number of choral and organ scholarships given for talent and dedication to the colleges’ music scenes. And yet it is perfectly possible to skip most lectures and not bother with class or tutorial work, and come out with a Distinction in Prelims and a shiny scholarship to go with it. The way scholarships and exhibitions are awarded at Oxford is an out-of-date system, not recognising true academic talent outside the limited examination system.

The fact that I am here at Oxford, the place I spent so much time and effort to get into, the university I both desired and feared, should be good enough for me. Wearing a fancier gown in front of my friends does not make me cleverer, nor does it make me feel superior to the coursemates who have taught me more than many lecturers could. The friendships I have made at university, the experiences I have had, the joy (and tears) in tutorials, the love and human connection – all these mean so much more than a piece of fabric. No one here should ever feel inferior because they didn’t excel at a set of, quite frankly, mocks. And so, if you see me in the marquee during Finals, I will be wearing my commoners’ gown proudly. I have nothing to prove to others: simply being at this university is reward enough for me.

Realisations of a country girl in Oxford

0

My home village, in the quiet countryside of Cheshire, has a population of 200. Within walking distance, you’ll find a church, a pub, and an upscale coffee shop for passing cyclists. If you want anything else, you’ll need a car – there’s no public transport here, unless you’re willing to tame one of the hundreds of cows scattered throughout the fields. Some of my fondest childhood memories are of damp and muddy Boxing Day rambles through the neighbouring farms, or board game nights when the weather wasn’t hospitable enough to be outside. After receiving an offer to study at Oxford, local scrutiny was everywhere. I couldn’t attend any local tractor run, village fête, or even birthday party without questions about my future following me wherever I went: a side effect of how few people, especially young people, were in the community.

By results day, the prospect of moving to Oxford had become a reality, and it wasn’t the intimidating reading list or the prestigious collegiate system that daunted me. It was the idea of living in the beating heart of a city that never seemed to sleep, where something was always happening. The perpetual chatter of tourists as they snake through the narrow alleyways to peer through the huge wooden doors of another college; the warble of buskers on Cornmarket Street, gathering crowds who toss pennies into their open guitar cases; the wailing of sirens as yet another ambulance drives beneath my bedroom window, startling me awake at night. It was all of these things that made the city feel more alive than anything I’d ever experienced at home. 

The streets of Oxford are like rivers. You are packed shoulder to shoulder in a flowing stream of people, each rushing off down their own channel. I often found myself longing to slow down and meander, like a duck floating downstream, admiring the rich history of my surroundings. That was my first lesson upon my arrival in the city: keep moving. Just as the city never stops, neither can you. Coming to a halt to admire a monument or ancient building will result in the agitated mutters of passers-by, inconvenienced by your wonder. 

On my way to a lecture at the Schwarzman Centre in my first week of Michaelmas, I remember slowing to read an inscription on a grave marker in the churchyard of St Giles’ (a reminder of the old churches I regularly encountered at home, being both a resident of a countryside village and the daughter of a rural priest). My curiosity was cut short when a woman, probably 20 years my senior, knocked me sideways and delivered a strongly worded admonishment I can’t replicate here. The whole interaction struck me as a little sad: humans are so focused on their own trivial goings-on that we find it so difficult to slow down and admire the things around us. Rather than let the city’s relentless pace deter me, I resolved to make the most of its history. I consider myself an expert at ducking out of people’s paths and taking every winding street to soak in everything I can. 

The city’s relative anonymity is another thing that takes some time getting used to. Where a passer-by might stop to chat with you on a rural country lane, the same privilege will not be extended to you down an Oxford alleyway. This reality hit me hard during my first time at the post office, sending letters home to my mother – perhaps an antiquated practice, but there’s something unmatched about the joy of popping a letter in a postbox, or receiving one in your pigeonhole after a difficult day. I was there not only sending letters but also buying postcards for future communications, chatting away merrily with the shopkeeper about the recipient of my letter, and some of its less personal contents. My enthusiasm, however, was met with little more than the occasional nod and a mildly judgemental stare. Equally, many students will whip by you, completely ignoring your smile, nod, or wave. Instead, their heads are down, puffer coats wrapped tightly around them (but rarely zipped, I’ve noticed), backpack or handbag slung over one shoulder, rushing to the library or the coffee shop or the lecture theatre. This surprised me at first, but now that my own classes and lectures have begun, I can sympathise with such individuals. For a student, life often seems to go faster than the average person, between laundry, meal prepping, and completing essays or problem sheets. Balancing the domestic with the academic takes a lot of energy, often leaving little to offer others.

And amid all this rushing around, there’s another challenge: knowing where to go. With so many places to eat, study, and visit, it’s easy to feel lost. Where before my choices were limited to my room, the garden, or a footpath, there are now countless places to explore. This newfound space will almost certainly affect how you study. Personally, this meant finding my feet incredibly quickly, without anyone to tell me quite how I was supposed to do it. The first thing you try is unlikely to be the strategy that sticks. I have played with my screen time, my study location, my social calendar, and found that my day sometimes feels like walking a tightrope between becoming a workaholic and a procrastinator. The allure of city life will distract you from work and likely drain your wallet (the thrill of actually being able to order pizza delivery still hasn’t left me). But don’t let the sheer volume of options overwhelm you. The core takeaway from my experience is to find your calm space amongst everything else going on in your life. Without it, the ebb and flow of Oxford will easily sweep you away with its tide. Finding peace and quiet stabilises you, offering somewhere to drop your anchor and rest for a while.

On the subject of finding calm, if in doubt, go back to what you know. Some days, I do my reading from my bedroom desk, a familiar setting I became all too acquainted with during my A-levels. Others, I take a walk around University Parks – the closest thing I have to walking through farm fields in the middle of Oxford. Above all, don’t put too much pressure on yourself to find your feet immediately. Adjusting to city life has been as much about learning to navigate Oxford as it has been about learning to live independently. When you return home for Christmas and find yourself begging your parents for yet another lift into town, you’ll miss how accessible the city can be. The freedom it brings is something impossible to find in the countryside, and something I’m sure I’ll grapple with when the time comes. For now, though, I’m learning to enjoy my newfound autonomy and the academic challenges of university without getting swept up in the rush, all the while being amazed at how far I’ve come.

One f**king thing after another: ‘The History Boys’, revisited

0

Grab your motorcycle helmet. Sharpen up on the subjunctive. And cue the synthetic pulses of ‘Blue Monday’. The History Boys is back.

Alan Bennett’s 2004 play followed a cast of candidates vying for an Oxbridge place. Last month it was announced that the play is set to return to the London stage at the Theatre Royal Haymarket early next year. But we may ask: what’s the point of this revival?

I have to confess that I’m not quite a dispassionate observer of what a 2013 poll found to be Britain’s best-loved play. Bennett numbers among my favourite playwrights, and The History Boys among my favourite plays. When applying to Oxford, I didn’t consider Jesus or Corpus, as Irwin failed to get in there. I’m aware this is hugely embarrassing.

Despite my love for it, it’s hardly an uncontroversial work. AQA chose to remove the play from its GCSE syllabus in 2022. The frequent gripe for a contemporary audience is the play’s disturbingly frequent gropes. The idolised general studies teacher Mr Hector fondles his pupils on the back of a motorcycle. Whilst they’re all adults (just about), the pedophilic behaviour is deeply uncomfortable, especially so given Bennett’s initial wish for student Posner’s voice to be unbroken.

Though Bennett acknowledges this as a fault (“a grope is a grope. It is not the annunciation”, the terrific Mrs Lintott bites), he treats it as no more than a foible in an otherwise idealised picture. The final scene glorifies Hector with a funeral no less exalting than that of his mythic namesake. In another particularly delightful line, the “big man” can refer either to God or Hector. This issue aside, the play also undoubtedly has an air of entitled schoolboy arrogance, though I think Bennett is partly aware of it. Think Dakin’s cocky declaration: “We are so fucking clever.”

Perhaps more compelling than these reasons not to stage the play is the seeming absence of any reason to stage it. What’s it for? Just a cash grab? Would Forty Years On not be a better choice, his moving school-play-within-a-play that reappraises a postwar, post-Suez Britain? Why The History Boys? Why now?

A tenuous case could be made for its particular relevance today. In Burnham’s Britain, burdened by housing crises and championing vocational education, it’s apt that the most brilliant success of the play is Rudge’s business building homes for first-time buyers, whilst Posner (the only one who took all Hector’s teaching to heart) is unhappy at Cambridge, and persists in parasitic nostalgia for his schoolboy days. However, when speaking to The Times, even director Sir Nicholas Hytner couldn’t stomach a “specious” claim about its pertinence to today’s conversations about the education system.

The revival seems to be Hytner’s idea. Sir Nick is brilliant. Balancing Acts, his memoir on twelve years as artistic director of the National Theatre, is a tremendous read. His 2013 production of Othello is electric, and One Man, Two Guvnors is deftly delightful. His film direction of The Madness of King George (1994) is excellent if only for the climax: “I am the King!”, George declares, strapped into a chair. “No, sir, you are the patient!” returns the doctor as Zadok the Priest swells in this perverse anti-coronation. But can’t he do better? Following The Standard of Living earlier this year, is rehashing this old work the best Hytner can bring to the West End?

Perhaps Bennett suffers from a similar condition. His last effort was the film The Choral (2025), which, whilst moving, was a touch derivative. It became a tick-box list of Bennettisms: passions unfulfilled, power of art, Yorkshire. A scene towards the end echoes Bennett’s admittedly devastating Talking Heads episode, ‘Waiting for the Telegram’. There’s a whiff of Posner to this revival: a reliance on younger, more successful days. We have a 2020s remake of a 2000s play set in the 1980s based on Bennett’s 1950s schoolboy years.

But try as I might to scoff at it, I can’t help but be excited by the return. Crowther’s elegy for Hector may work well as a verdict on the play itself: “He was stained and shabby and did unforgivable things.” But “even his death was a lesson that added to the store”.

In all its blemished brilliance, The History Boys has lessons to add to the store. It speaks to us about the value of education, the struggles of growing up, and – perhaps most fascinatingly – the “sheer randomness of history”. Dakin’s discussions of how history happens, the unpredictability of Halifax’s teeth winning Britain the war, Rudge’s declaration that it’s just “one f***ing thing after another”, even the boys’ playing around “in the subjunctive mood”; these are all questions that play out in the narrative itself, with Hector’s potential expulsion, and the plot (and motorbike’s) lurch.

Whilst it’s easy to mock the play’s soppy view of literature, it’s both intensely moving and true. A poem can be that hand across history, reaching out and holding yours. The cast of characters is vividly sketched, from the plight of love-sick Posner serenading his unrequited sweetheart with Ella Fitzgerald, to the swaggering arrogance of Dakin, the razor-sharp satire of revisionist Irwin, and the no-nonsense and brilliantly perceptive Rudge.

It’s also great fun. Bennett captures the playful musicality of schoolboys teasing teachers: “Are jokes gonna be a feature, sir?” The film adaptation (a guilty pleasure) is similarly charming. It adds Penelope Wilton as an Art History teacher brushing the boys up in culture, and Adrian Scarborough as a devoutly religious press-up-demanding PE teacher (“give me 20!”, “what? Hail Mary’s?”).

These lessons might not be much, but, to butcher AE Housman’s words: all plays are worthwhile whether or not they serve the slightest human use. The History Boys numbers among them.

“Why now?”, we may ask. “Why not?”, we may answer. I’ll see you at the Royal Haymarket.