Books, not saline solution against tear gas, are what you’d expect to find in a schoolbag. This isn’t the case for most of my friends back home right now. Since September in France, a wave of protests against failing education, austerity, and the far-right have swept the country. Many talk of a new May 1968, the glorified student movement and nationwide strike. But the failed promises of a revolution are no longer echoed in the halls of Sorbonne University. High schoolers as young as 13 have shown us that political action requires less intellectualism and more strategy, using Snapchat to mobilise because it is their only social media. It’s different from the movement at the end of the sixties because it’s reverberating all across the globe with the speed of the internet; a Student Spring is rising.
From school to university lectures, I have always found it difficult to learn about social justice and the merits of advocacy while being violently repressed for expressing these values. I feel anger, like most students do. When we were told that fascism never shows up as itself but instead as aestheticised popular trends, I had to practice cognitive dissonance to not notice it everywhere. At a university like Oxford, this discord didn’t get any better. I was directed toward Google Forms about collective grievances because “protesting inconveniences others”.
On a FlixBus back from Paris, I heard someone in the next seat criticising the protests. It felt alienating to hear someone misconstrue a struggle you so deeply care about in ten seconds. I thank this person, however, for calling the movement part of a wider Student Spring. Taking its name from the Arab Spring of 2011, those protests fundamentally changed how youth social movements interact with political power in a digital age, with platforms like Facebook helping millions to mobilise against dictatorship. The current Student Spring testifies to the resilience of our generation and the convergence among social struggles.
As I watch unarmed and peaceful students choke on chemical irritants in the water cannons aimed at them, I recall my own experiences of getting tear gas grenades thrown at my feet. Tear gas has recently been scrutinised for its long-term effects like miscarriages or total blindness. The illegality of all of these violent methods is what strikes me; most of the weapons used in France are classified as wartime artillery. UN experts have expressed their concern about the crackdown on these student protests, as France recently deployed the army as reinforcement. Medical reinforcement does not seem to be coming through; in October, my friends and I, along with a volunteer student medic, were the only ones available to help a man struck to the bone by a grenade.
As disproportionate as these measures may seem, they prove just how powerful students are. In under two years of daily protest across the country, students in Serbia achieved the resignation of their populist leader who had been in various positions of power for 14 years. I remember visiting my cousins during the holidays, and nothing had paused. We chanted through the streets of Novi Sad every single evening. In Albania, students are also taking the matter into their own hands, many of whom are playing an active role in their ongoing ‘Flamingo Revolution’. The ‘Cockroach Janta’ student party in India, as in France, called for the resignation of their education secretary. Repressed by lathi baton charges, a colonial-era tactic where police use batons to scatter crowds, reports from Reuters have shown that pellet guns and Varifocal bullet cameras are not territorially confined.
Back in the UK, there is currently less of a culture centred around protest. I believe this disadvantages students. When university fees in the UK tripled to £9,000 in 2010, the protests were vilified in the same way as those in France. The government hoped students would drown in specialised research and ignore their unemployability, recently exemplified by funding cuts to the humanities.
At times, my university feels like a self-contained universe, a playground for ideas, not action. Our moral and communal responsibilities are delayed by learning their history or debating their justifications. My tutorials on utilitarianism and contractualism have taught me this. Universities are both the machines and the victims of the ideology we are taught about. But fear not, a Student Spring is blooming.
Caterina Azzara: If democracy listens, why are the streets full?
I was always told to study. Education, the story went, was the price of a voice: learn enough, and one day people would have to listen. But what happens when the state forgets its side of that promise?
The first answer came from France. Students at Lycée Saint-Exupéry in Créteil, a suburb just south-east of Paris, joined a strike called by their teachers on 21st September and blocked the school, which had gone months without enough teachers or support staff. Within around ten days, the vacancies had been filled, and the blockade in Créteil came to an end. By then, however, the discontent had travelled via social media to other high schools around Paris, and by early October more than 1,000 schools across France had been disrupted. The main pupils’ union set out its demands: more teachers, safe buildings, smaller classes, and the abolition of Parcoursup, the platform that has controlled access to French universities since 2018. By 17th October, joined by teachers and trade unions, the movement had merged with a national protest against the cost of living, which brought nearly 800,000 people onto the streets according to the unions, while the Interior Minister put the figure at 550,000.
Inspired by the French, Italian students took to the streets on 16th October, marching through Milan, Turin, Rome, Naples, Bologna, and Genoa under the banner of “No Meloni Day”, in reference to Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. They were protesting against crumbling school buildings, a decree imposing a 30% cap per class on students with non-Italian citizenship, and an inadequate education budget. The timing gave their protest particular force as it coincided with the government’s spending plans for next year: while Cittadinanzattiva recorded 68 structural collapses in Italian schools over the past year, the draft budget for 2027, approved by the cabinet on 13th October, makes room for roughly €7 billion in additional defence spending. Hence the central demand of the student collective Osa: that the €13 billion earmarked for new weapons be converted immediately into funds for school buildings.
As the marches grew, so did the violence. In France, 24 schools were burned or ransacked, while protests in Milan and Turin ended in clashes with police. I will not justify it for two simple reasons. The first is that it does nothing to help the cause. In Why Civil Resistance Works (2011), a study of 323 campaigns between 1900 and 2006, political scientists Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan found that nonviolent movements succeeded twice as often as violent ones, because they attract far more participants and because repressing peaceful crowds tends to cost a government support. Omar Wasow’s 2020 study of the 1960s American civil rights movement reached a similar conclusion: peaceful marches won public sympathy, whereas riots frightened voters into backing candidates who promised ‘law and order’, tougher policing rather than the reforms protesters demanded. The second reason is that violence buries the cause it claims to serve. Media scholars call this the protest paradigm, in which cameras linger on the burning bin rather than the classroom without a teacher. In France, the Education Minister called the movement “taken hostage by ultra-violent groups”, and the debate shifted from missing teachers to public order.
Yet to dwell on the violence is to miss the more pressing question: why do so many young people feel that protest is the only way to be heard? The question matters because being heard is what democracy promises, and both the French and Italian constitutions place power in the hands of the people. Political theorist Robert Dahl argued that a democracy is judged not only by its elections but by how well it listens to its citizens in between. By that standard, a 16-year-old who barricades her school in order to get a teacher is not attacking democracy; she is exposing its failure.
Oxford City Council has approved the development of 78 new homes as part of their affordable housing target.
The developments will be spread across Cowley, East Oxford, and Wood Farm, with the construction managed by OX Place, Oxford City Council’s housing development company. The aim of the developments, according to the council, is to “increase the supply of genuinely affordable housing across the city”.
The plans include 28 new flats in Kersington Crescent, 47 flats on 474 Cowley Road, and two houses on the Wood Farm estate. The houses and flats will either be for affordable rent or social rent, and many will act as temporary accommodation for single homeless adults.
This is the council’s latest project under a rolling affordable housing target. Within this period, the council aims to provide 1,600 affordable homes.
These newest developments come at a time when demand for affordable housing in Oxford is significantly higher than supply. According to the City Council’s latest data, over 4,000 applicants are on the social housing register. Planning restrictions and flood risks in and around the city make it difficult for new housing to be easily and cheaply built.
Oxford houses are also expensive in comparison with average wages in Oxford. Data published in a 2026 Centre for Cities report shows Oxford as the least affordable city in the UK for housing, with average house prices of £549,600, compared to average annual wages of £44,000. The report notes that in cities like Oxford “high house prices are not matched by high levels of housing supply, with the planning system acting as a key constraint on building both upwards and outwards”.
In an online statement, Linda Smith, Councillor and Cabinet Member for Housing and Communities, praised the developments as “opportunities to provide homes for people who need them at a time when demand has never been so high”.
“There is a huge need for affordable housing in Oxford, and we know we cannot solve that overnight. But brick by brick, site by site, we are delivering the homes Oxford needs.”
Oxford City Council’s housing policy has its critics. Layla Moran, MP for West Oxford and Abingdon, told Cherwell: “Oxford City Council is good at making a very large amount of noise every time it delivers a very small number of houses.
“The City Council has consistently failed to deliver anywhere near the number of homes needed and has repeatedly prioritised commercial development over housing when large sites have become available.”
Moran also claimed that, in contrast, neighbouring Liberal Democrat-led councils have consistently delivered on affordable housing.
A campaign group made up of more than 800 families harmed during their maternity care at Oxford University Hospitals (OUH) are calling for an independent investigation into its services. In an open letter addressed to the Health Secretary, parents have raised concerns that a national inquiry conducted earlier this year failed to “capture the complexity of families’ accounts and the recurring pattern of harm described” because of the use of AI to complete the investigation and conflicting interests of senior NHS members.
Parents treated by OUH’s maternity ward say that their concerns “were not being adequately investigated or taken seriously” during their treatment at the hospital.
An affected mother recalled how, during a complicated and distressing labour, a member of staff “entered the room and handed me paperwork asking what we wanted to happen to our baby’s remains. There had been no bereavement discussion. Nobody had explained that my daughter was going to die. Yet I was being asked to consider what should happen to her body before she had even been born.” Her baby was successfully delivered and did not die. She described her labour as “one of the most traumatic and devastating experiences of my life.”
“At times I felt procedures were being carried out before I had even understood what was happening,” she told Cherwell. “I remember a midwife having to remind the other professionals in the room to introduce themselves”.
OUH encompasses four Oxfordshire hospitals, including the John Radcliffe Hospital, which work with the University to deliver education and training to doctors. The University’s Vice-Chancellor, Professor Irene Tracey, is co-chair of OUH Strategic Board. It was one of fourteen NHS Trusts identified by then-Health Secretary Wes Streeting in September 2025 as requiring urgent review.
Baroness Valerie Amos, Master at University College, chaired the investigation, which intended to make recommendations to improve care and safety in maternity and neonatal care and promised to “put families at the heart of the work”.
Amos’s investigation, which was published in June this year, concluded that there was “evidence of a willingness to ignore national guidelines based on evidence in favour of what Oxford clinicians think is the better way”. One staff member called this “the Oxford way”, adding that “it is the best” and “woe betide you if you challenge it.”
The report additionally flagged staffing issues, finding that overnight medical cover at the John Radcliffe Hospital was “not an appropriate staffing model for a unit of this size” and that leaders have “limited insight” into staff distress and its operational causes.
One mother told Cherwell that while she was initially told that her daughter was in relatively good condition for her age, she has since discovered information indicating that respiratory equipment malfunctioned during her daughter’s resuscitation, and that she was subsequently placed on alternative respiratory equipment because the intended machine was unavailable.
She continues to attend investigations and specialist appointments at OUH, including sleep studies and neurological assessments, to monitor and treat the life-threatening conditions which her daughter has incurred since delivery.
“One of the most difficult aspects of this journey is the uncertainty,” she says. “We are constantly trying to understand whether her symptoms represent changes in her neurological condition, whether further intervention will be necessary, and what this could mean for her future.”
Initially, OUH were not considered for the Amos investigation because their perinatal data did not necessitate “urgent measures”. However, grassroots campaigns by FFOUH, Keep the Norton General, and lobbying by local MPs raised attention to severe patient complaints surrounding communication and consent.
A report made by FFOUH, containing testimonies from more than 700 patients, was submitted for consideration in the Amos investigation last November. However, it appears that expert advisors within the Amos investigation did not even view the report, according to Dr Bill Krikup.
Krikup resigned from the Amos investigation prior to its publication, stating that the review was changed just days before publication to remove criticism of natural birth ideology where patients were discouraged from caesarean sections and using pain relief.
Parents are criticising the reliance on artificial intelligence to analyse sensitive family testimonials and evidence submissions in the Amos investigation which failed to recognise the complexity of the families’ accounts and the recurring patterns of the harm they detected, in particular “the influence of birth ideology and the conduct of key staff members”.
“This means that the harm in Oxford has never been properly analysed”, the letter states. “Lessons cannot have been adequately captured and women and babies in Oxfordshire remain at risk.” Cherwell understands that the families who submitted evidence did not consent to their personal testimonies or sensitive health data being analysed by AI.
An affected parent told Cherwell: “Families like mine have relived deeply traumatic experiences to provide evidence, hoping our voices would finally be heard and meaningful changes would follow. Learning that artificial intelligence was used to assist in analysing testimonies raises concerns about whether important details, patterns of poor care and patient safety warnings may have been overlooked.”
Parents have criticised unequal treatment between hospitals involved in the Amos investigation since its publication. An independent investigation has been ordered at Leeds University Hospitals after a report of at least 56 potentially preventable baby deaths, meanwhile a review commissioned for University Hospitals Sussex after at least 55 preventable baby deaths were identified.
The open letter asks why Oxford has not received equivalent scrutiny, despite a similar BBC investigation reporting that 58 baby deaths were potentially avoidable at OUH between 2019 and 2024. Speaking to Cherwell, an affected parent who volunteers at FFOUH said “we have to address the elephant in the room: reputation and protectionism.”
FFOUH also said an independent investigation is needed and expressed distrust over conflict of interests in the Amos investigation. FOIs obtained from the Department of Health and Social Care show that the data analysed by AI was held by NHS England. The CEO of OUH was recently seconded to Deputy CEO of NHS England, and the Trust’s chair has recently taken a regional role there. Families have expressed concern about their sensitive health data and said an investigation commissioned or influenced by OUH or bodies closely tied to it “would not gain families’ trust and would not be credible”.
Rebecca, the co-founder of FFOUH, told Cherwell that though OUH have responded to individual situations raised by patients, they have “focussed on reputation management instead of addressing the issues raised adequately. There has to be accountability for the harm, and the changes are surface-level and many appear to be ‘for show’.”
They claim that they have been met with “defensiveness and families left having to try and prove they are telling the truth”.
In a statement to Cherwell, Professor Meghana Pandit, Chief Executive Officer at OUH, said: “We are very sorry for the poor experience that some mothers and families have had in our care. This is below the standards that we aim to deliver for our patients.
“The Trust remains fully committed to learning from every family’s experience and to continuously improve the quality of maternity care. We encourage women and families to communicate with us so we can learn from them and work with them to address the areas where care may have fallen short.”
Speaking to Cherwell, one parent said that “one of the most significant consequences has been the complete breakdown of my trust in healthcare professionals. After repeatedly feeling that my concerns were dismissed, I now find myself constantly questioning, researching and documenting everything to ensure [my daughter] receives appropriate care.
There is a particular kind of grief in watching your child endure so much, while knowing that some of the answers you desperately need may never come.”
A worldwide Microsoft outage has taken down Outlook at the University of Oxford. The outage began on Thursday evening and had not been fixed at the time of publication.
In a statement, the University said the outage “is affecting some University systems, including Outlook, which is currently unavailable”. It added that it was “actively monitoring” the situation and posting updates on status.ox.ac.uk. Students and staff use Microsoft’s 365 service for email, calendar, and Teams.
On the outage tracker Downdetector, UK reports of problems with Microsoft Outlook in the UK first spiked at 6pm yesterday, passing 3000. As of 8am today, over 7000 issues had been reported.
Microsoft said a number of its servers had become “unexpectedly unavailable”, which put an “elevated load” on the rest of its infrastructure. The company has so far said there is no sign it was a cybersecurity incident.
Update 11:30am
The University’s status page is now showing “partial” issues with Student Records (SITS: Vision), the back-end database used to manage student records. The student-facing side of the system – eVision and the Student Self Service – is still listed as working as normal. The University has not said whether the SITS: Vision outage is linked to the wider Microsoft outage, which is still affecting Nexus365 systems in Oxford.
Microsoft has said it has made “additional progress toward service recovery”. The company added that it has finished recovery work in parts of the Asia Pacific region. There, it said, “traffic is being gradually restored”.
The company said it has now extended recovery actions to other regions but did not provide a timeline.
Update 4:00pm
The University told Cherwell that “teaching, student support, and other University activities are continuing wherever possible”, as the Microsoft outage continues. The University added that staff and students “are being advised to use alternative contact methods”.
In a statement, the University told Cherwell: “A global Microsoft service outage is affecting a number of University IT systems, particularly email, calendars and services that depend on them. The impact varies between users, and IT Services is working with the University’s incident response teams to assess the disruption and provide guidance.
“We are monitoring the situation closely and will provide further updates on OxIntranet and the University’s IT status page as more information becomes available.”
Separately, the University said some student support staff, including its admissions, student records, and assessment team, were unable to log in to SITS: Vision this morning because of a problem with a server. The University added that the system is stable following a reboot, and that “there is nothing to indicate this is linked to” the Microsoft outage.
Microsoft has said the company is seeing “sustained improvements in service availability as recovery process continues”. As of the time of publication, the University’s status page is still showing “partial” issues with Nexus365.
Update 14th November
The University’s status page is now showing no more issues with Nexus365. Microsoft has said it is “deeply sorry” as service gradually returned yesterday.
Protesters placed a Ku Klux Klan (KKK) hood and sign on the statue of Cecil Rhodes on the college outside High Street, with a sign reading: “Racists welcome here.” The demonstration comes days before Nathan Cofnas’ controversial talk at the college.
The activist group Led By Donkeys confirmed their responsibility for the demonstration to Cherwell. In a statement, the group told Cherwell they had deployed a cherry-picker and “gave [the statue] a makeover”.
The white pointed hood is a symbol associated with the American far-right hate group, the KKK. During the late 19th and 20th centuries, the group was famous for peddling white supremacist ideology and racial violence.
Led By Donkeys told Cherwell: “This intervention was in solidarity with decades of students attending this university who have opposed its cosy relationship with white supremacists.”
In their Instagram post, they mention the college’s hosting of Cofnas, describing him as a “white supremacist” who “kick-started the campaign against Professor Jason Arday”.
“But this is the college staying true to form”, the post says. “It continues to display this statue of Cecil Rhodes, the notorious imperialist who created brutally racist colonies in southern Africa.”
The statue of the 19th-century British imperialist has sparked numerous controversies in recent years. Rhodes has long been a polemic figure for his role in the British colonisation of Southern Africa. He was directly involved in the violent conquest of what is now Zambia and Zimbabwe as well as exploitative labour practices and racial segregation in South Africa as head of the De Beers mining company.
Rhodes was a former Oriel student and founded the eponymous Rhodes Scholarship scheme, which funds international postgraduate students at the University of Oxford. In recent years, the scholarships have been subject to much scrutiny due to Rhodes’ colonial legacy. Meanwhile, the Rhodes Trust , who fund the scholarships, have faced financial difficulties.
Protests have demanded the removal of his statue since 2015, when the #RhodesMustFall movement began. The murder of George Floyd in 2020 led to further demonstrations.
Rhodes Must Fall Oxford, who led the movement, have called the statue a “visual marker of the priorities of this institution. It offers a clear public reflection of who the University of Oxford was designed to serve and who it was designed to exploit”.
Rather than removing the statue, Oriel agreed to establish a task force to consider recommendations for contextualising it, in line with a commissioned report. This involved an exhibition last year aiming to “contextualise the legacy of Cecil Rhodes”.
Student societies condemned Oriel College’s decision not to remove the statue in 2021, despite recommendations from an independent commission. At the time, Oriel defended their decision to maintain the statue’s place, citing “regulatory and financial challenges.” Cherwell understands Oriel risks sponsorship loss should the college remove the statue.
The post on Led By Donkeys was shared in collaboration with Black Lives Matter UK, Misan Harriman, and the account Everyday Racism.
At yesterday’s Extraordinary Conference of Common Rooms (CCR), Lord Mendoza, Provost of Oriel, confirmed that the location of Cofnas’ talk has been changed within the college due to student welfare concerns.
Han Willhoft-King is not simply another athletic student in their second year at Oxford. Only 10% of applicants to Oxford’s Law course receive an offer each year. Fewer than 1% of footballers in England progress to U21 academy level. Reaching both is almost unheard of. Yet Willhoft-King has done precisely that.
Willhoft-King is now studying Law at Brasenose College, after walking away from Manchester City’s academy and the prospect of working under the likes of Pep Guardiola.
Having risen through Tottenham Hotspur’s academy ranks between U16 and U18 level, Willhoft-King appeared destined for a different path. A scholarship to the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) offered him the opportunity to continue his academic studies alongside Division I football in the US, with the ultimate ambition of being drafted into Major League Soccer (MLS). But just days before he was due to board his flight, Manchester City came calling, offering a year-long contract at U21 level. It was an opportunity few could turn down. Training alongside the likes of Kevin De Bruyne and Phil Foden, matched with Yaya Toure’s experience as coach, Willhoft-King found himself closer than ever to breaking into professional football.
Yet, when we sat down with him, the conversation quickly turned to the reality behind the glamour of elite football. He spoke candidly about the “all or nothing” nature of academy life. Living arrangements ranged from foster families outside Manchester to apartment blocks shared with fellow players, whilst curfews were “closely monitored”. Academy football, he explained, “has to become your life” if you are to stand any chance of making it. The commitment is absolute, yet the rewards are far from guaranteed. Injuries, in particular, can bring years of dedication to an abrupt halt.
Despite the close friendships formed within the academy, the environment’s competitive nature inevitably creates tensions. As Willhoft-King acknowledged, “it is difficult when you are both competing for a single contract”. For many academy players, football represents far more than a sporting ambition: it is their perceived route to a livelihood. Even when support structures are in place, the stakes are exceptionally high. Though he has stepped away from the academy system, Willhoft-King remains in contact with many of his former teammates and reflects on the precariousness of their careers: “They break into the starting XI, and then they get injured, or the team signs a new player in their position, and they’re out, that’s it.” His reflections offer a sobering insight into a system in which years of commitment can be undone in an instant.
Absolute commitment to the academy pathway often comes at the expense of academic pursuits. Willhoft-King, however, evidently bucked this trend. Maintaining such dedication to both football and academia was not without its sacrifices. He recalls attending only one or two parties throughout his sixth-form years. Nevertheless, when asked how he managed to balance the two pursuits, he acknowledged the pressures involved but ultimately viewed them as complementary.
Football, he explained, provided an effective release from the demands of intense academic work. His family further supported this balance, as they never placed pressure on him to prioritise one pursuit over the other. His father, himself an Oxford professor, was particularly well placed to understand the demands of academic life, whilst appreciating the commitment required to pursue football at an elite level. As Willhoft-King recalls, “there was no external pressure” from his family regarding the balance between the two.
The conversation then turned to his transition from Manchester City to Oxford. Few experience the demands of a rigorous university application process whilst still on the books at one of the country’s elite football academies. Yet, Willhoft-King suggested that many of the lessons instilled during his academy years have proved invaluable in navigating Oxford’s own pressurised environment. He drew parallels between the demands of academic deadlines and the uncompromising standards of professional football. He recalled how arriving as little as “ten seconds late to a team meeting” could result in being dropped from the starting XI, an illustration of the discipline demanded at the highest level.
Having stepped away from the professional game, Willhoft-King has since established himself as a key figure in the Oxford Men’s Blues side. The transition has been a welcome one. He emphasises the enjoyment he derives from continuing to play competitive football within such a “close-knit team”. Away from the pressures of contracts, career progression and the uncertainty of the professional game, he appears to have found a sporting environment in which he can simply enjoy playing football. In many respects, it represents a refreshing contrast to the unforgiving nature of the academy system.
Looking ahead, Willhoft-King discusses the possibility of returning to professional football after completing his degree. Although professional clubs remain in contact with Oxford, he appears to have largely ruled out that path. Instead, he hopes to continue playing semi-professionally alongside a career as a lawyer. Given the increasingly prominent legal disputes surrounding top-flight football, his interest in practising sports law seems particularly fitting. Willhoft-King expresses a desire to work within the sport that has shaped so much of his life. Having experienced first-hand the inner workings of some of football’s most prestigious academies, he would bring a perspective to the legal profession that few other aspiring lawyers could.
For now, his focus remains on balancing life at Oxford with his continued involvement in Blues football. Having experienced the extraordinary demands of the professional academy pathway, Willhoft-King has found a different way to pursue both his academic and sporting ambitions. His journey is a reminder that leaving the professional game need not mean leaving football behind.
The Oxford Student Union (SU) and the Conference of Common Rooms (CCR) have released a statement that “unequivocally condemns” the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society’s (OURS) invitation to Nathan Cofnas. Cofnas, a self-described “race realist”, is due to speak at Oriel College on Tuesday.
The statement follows the motion ‘No Hate Speech at Oxford’. JCR and MCR representatives voted on the motion after yesterday’s Extraordinary CCR meeting.
The statement reads: “In an institution such as Oxford where people of colour are historically under-represented, it is the responsibility of all of us to make Oxford inclusive and to speak up against racism. Let there be no doubt. Black and Ethnic Minority students and staff are indivisible parts of our community at Oxford.”
The SU and CCR also affirmed their “joint commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion”. The statement condemns “any attempt to erode DEI, and any action which may endanger the well-being of Black and Ethnic Minority students and staff.”
“For both transparency and accountability, we urge Oriel College to publish its freedom of speech legal analysis and risk assessment of the Nathan Cofnas’ speaker event”, the statement continues. It adds that every risk assessment of a campus event should require “an equality risks assessment”, and that the Cofnas’ event “should require an independent review”.
St Catherine’s MCR President Xiangyue Wang proposed the motion, and five others seconded it, including SU President for Welfare, Equity, and Inclusion Catherine Kola-Balogun.
The motion also mandates the SU to spend £1,000 on diversity initiatives and to ask the University’s Proctors to attend the event in case a speech violates the 2010 Equality Act.
Merton JCR President Abdul Olagunju-Adekunle told Cherwell: “The importance of academic freedom and freedom of speech has been made quite clear by the University. Having said that, in my view, this motion represents a wholesale rejection of Cofnas’ views by the student body.”
Magdalen JCR President Isabella Taylor also told Cherwell the Magdalen JCR committee “condemn[s] the invitation of Nathan Cofnas”.
At Wednesday’s meeting, Oriel Provost Lord Mendoza confirmed that there were no plans to cancel Cofnas’ talk. He said the College consulted lawyers, who unanimously maintain that it must take place under the 2023 Free Speech Act. An Oriel spokesperson previously told Cherwell that permission “does not imply endorsement”, and that the College is committed to “promoting inclusion and maintaining an environment that is free from all forms of discrimination and harassment”.
Cofnas, a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University, publicised allegations of plagiarism against Jasan Arday, who became the University of Cambridge’s youngest Black professor in 2023. Arday, who denied the allegations and was later cleared of wrongdoing, was found dead earlier this year.
The motion argues that Cofnas’ invitation “shows a concerning lack of consideration for the situation, but also a lack of sensitivity in thinking of its effects on Oxford students and staff”. It adds that the event will likely “have a negative impact on the wellbeing of Black students and staff at the University of Oxford and higher education throughout the UK”.
Opposition to the event has included a statement by 49 Oriel SCR members condemning Nathan Cofnas, along with an open letter and a protest planned by Stand Up To Racism.
In June, the University of Oxford published its Annual Admissions Statistics Report, an extensive document detailing the domicile, nation and region, disadvantage, school type, gender, ethnicity, and disability of most undergraduate applicants from 2021 to 2025. It found, interestingly, that the proportion of state-educated, UK-domiciled undergraduates admitted between 2021 and 2025 decreased from 68.2% to 66.5%. This is perhaps cause for concern for many outreach departments across the University, but I propose that there is an even broader issue: the way we define ‘state school’.
The Admissions Report splits the English education system into two wide categories of ‘state’ and ‘independent’. These categories broadly align with the simple question: did you pay to go to school or not? It is clear to me that the distinction in the report is intended to answer said question, and in that sense it does fulfil its purpose. In reality, however, England’s education system is far more complex, encompassing faith schools, free schools (state-funded but not run by the local authority), and academies. But when it comes to university admissions, the corresponding distinction in secondary education is that of state comprehensive, grammar, and private schools. Both the definition and importance of the three owe much to their shared history.
The system we see today stems from the Tripartite System, a product of the 1944 Education Act. Those who passed an exam akin to the 11+ were able to attend a prestigious grammar school, while those who failed had to choose between a secondary modern or a technical school. While at first praised for creating opportunities for the working class, who previously had to pay for their education, the Tripartite System soon became controversial, owing to the admissions test which often barred the working class from entry to grammar schools. Private and public schools, in which education cost a hefty fee, were still options for the wealthy.
The Tripartite System was replaced in the 1960s and 1970s by comprehensive schools. These schools did not select students based on income or academic merit, and instead admitted students in the local catchment area. As with most aspects of English society, the tides turned yet again in the 1980s, with Margaret Thatcher’s 1980 Education Act. ‘Marketisation’ of the education system meant that parents had greater choice in which school their child went to, and we still live with this system today. Comprehensive and private schools are still actively established across the country, but grammar schools have been abolished – it is no longer legal to set one up, but those of the past often continue with the grammar school name.
The historic divide between the secondary modern (roughly akin to the modern comprehensive) and the grammar school endures in the present day. There is a lot to praise the grammar school system for, such as the high standards of education that do not come with a price tag. Nevertheless, several material factors affect a child’s access to grammar schools. While in theory any child can take the 11+ exam, this may be an impractical burden for those not living near a grammar school, and like any exam, those who can afford private tuition are placed in a better position than those who cannot. According to the UCL Institute of Education, children from higher socio-economic backgrounds are far more likely to attend a grammar school than a child from a lower socio-economic background.
Once at school, social factors begin to shape each child’s future. Simply being in a classroom with high-achieving peers is a significant motivator, and primes students for study at a top university. While each person has a different view of their own time at school, I can say for myself that going to a comprehensive school did make me feel inferior, especially in terms of the facilities and resources offered at grammar and private schools. Why did fortune mean that I couldn’t access such resources? Growing up in that environment, I had never met someone who went to a grammar or private school until attending Oxford, and I admittedly thought very badly of those who did: being out of touch, posh, and entitled were stereotypes I fully believed in. But with these stereotypes also came the feeling that these people were better than me, as beneficiaries of fortune’s natural favour.
These factors translate into university admissions statistics. A report by the Sutton Trust found that of the top 100 schools with the highest Oxford admission rates, 78 were independent, 21 were grammar, and only 1 was comprehensive. There are only 163 grammar schools in England, but talking to students at Oxford may lead you to think that they constitute a far higher proportion of the country’s 6,000 secondary schools. However, there’s simply no way of discerning just how many of Oxford’s state-educated students went to grammar schools, because this information is not reflected in the data.
More importantly, without a more detailed impression of school type, it is much more difficult for departments and colleges to gauge the success of outreach and access initiatives. The 66.5% of Oxford students who attended a state school may actually be a combination of 90% grammar and 10% comprehensive, but we do not have access to this information, leaving us unable to determine if an initiative is actually working. Other measures do exist, including Free School Meals eligibility and Index of Multiple Deprivation, but if the aim is to increase the general number of applicants from state comprehensives, these alternative measures do not map neatly – roughly 90% of pupils in the UK attend a state comprehensive, while around 26% are eligible for Free School Meals. It is important that outreach be extended to both groups, and they often do overlap, but the University’s current state-school measure is unhelpful in this context.
I want to emphasise that this problem is not unique to Oxford. The University of Bristol, for example, uses the same broad categorisation. However, the University of Cambridge does distinguish between types of state school in their own statistics. If anything, my aim is simply to open up the discussion about education. Anecdotally, I’ve had peers at Oxford try to relate to me through our shared state education, but it falls flat for me when it becomes clear that this state school was in fact a grammar school.
For me, at least, while there can certainly be students at grammar schools who experience material hardship, these institutions are not the same at all. Grammar schools can be beneficial to a child’s education, and some are among the top-performing schools in the country, but it is a disservice to the lived experience of state comprehensive students to bind us together in admissions statistics.
In response, the University of Oxford told Cherwell: “Oxford’s access efforts focus on measures of disadvantage, for which school type is a poor proxy. The University uses a range of contextual information such as individual level indicators of disadvantage, postcode indicators of disadvantage, and school performance during the undergraduate admissions process.
This includes: additional Widening Participation (WP) information, information about an applicant’s school, information about an applicant’s neighbourhood, any experience in the care system, eligibility for Free School Meals (FSM) since age 11.”
“If they tell me to take it off, I won’t do that, and I will leave the school because the hijab is more important to me than the school. It’s the most important thing in my life”
-Hijab-wearing schoolgirl Florinda Zeka, 2010 BBC interview about Kosovo’s hijab ban in schools.
For me, one of the most challenging aspects of wearing a veil is being at the receiving end of attempts to unveil you. I personally first encountered this at age ten, when Ofsted decided to target visibly Muslim primary school girls across the country and ask them why they wore the hijab and whether they are forced, in front of their peers. Many other visibly Muslim girls and I grew up being the target of interrogations while facing demands to condemn the two countries which imposed veiling on women. Meanwhile, we endured watching more European countries like France, Austria, Norway, Netherlands, Germany, Belgium, Kosovo, Russia (in areas like Stavropol Krai and Mordovia), Spain, Italy, and Switzerland banning the hijab and/or niqab in educational institutions.
While our peers in these countries were fighting for their religious freedoms and right to an education, we grew up very aware of the stereotypes attached to the hijab, including being thought of as uneducated or less ambitious. We grew up being told that the hijab is a backward, alien, or unnatural practice despite the fact that women veiling is as old as civilisation itself. I cannot think of a practice that unites more women globally than veiling. From England to Assyria to Greece to India and even further afield, women have traditionally veiled for either cultural or religious reasons.
The stereotype of veiled Muslim women lacking basic skills, basic education, or being confined to their homes is the one that has had the most impact on my self-image as I began to veil. I have had to remember to stop viewing myself through a lens of ‘double-consciousness’, a sociological term meaning to constantly measure and view oneself through the prejudiced eyes, stereotypes, and contempt of the dominant culture.
When I decided to wear the hijab in primary school, I was ridiculed and excluded by close friends. On World Book Day, for instance, I was told that I could not be Matilda, like all the other girls in my class, because “she never wears a scarf”. Gradually, I stopped many activities like drama, and felt discouraged ice skating, since I was influenced into thinking that certain activities look silly in a hijab. Giving up on hobbies however, is not much in comparison to girls who are denied an education, or offered a conditional education that compromises their religious freedoms and choice.
During my first year, when someone at the Oxford Union was speaking in an emergency debate about feminism and women’s education, I reminded him that such education does not extend to women like me in many European countries. In reply, he said: “I think it is a great privilege you have to be speaking in a place like this.”
While the international community and women’s rights activists look the other way, veiled Muslim girls are fighting one of the hardest battles to attend school. The psychological trauma and violence of forced unveiling is a lived reality for so many veiled Muslim girls, both throughout history and across the world today. There are more countries in the world that force Muslim women to remove our veils than those that impose them, yet we grew up very aware that most people assume that we are unable to make our own choices about our own bodies and are forced.
At a society event I attended in Oxford during my first year, someone asked me why I still wear a scarf and whether I was forced to. I told her, mindful to do so gracefully, that this is never forced. She replied: “No, you are, because if you don’t you go to hell.” I told her that Muslims do not weaponise or invoke hell upon each other and that God is the ultimate judge. She carried on following me across the room, insulting me and questioning me about Iranian law, despite me telling her that I am not only not Iranian but that there are many women in Iran who no longer veil. As expected, nobody else in the room told her to stop harassing me.
I think about this moment most, because while today the hijab and/or niqab is banned in educational spaces across Europe, the overwhelming majority of people not only do not condemn this, but do not question it either. Only 50% of Western Europeans favour allowing Muslim women to wear religious clothing in any setting (with this still excluding face coverings), while 23% favour a ban on all religious clothing.
In UK schools, there have been many cases of both teachers and other pupils forcefully pulling Muslim girls’ hijabs. Some UK schools have also banned the hijab. Forced unveiling of any kind not only removes our identities from educational spaces and public life, but as a result of our absence, also reinforces the stereotypes of us as intellectually deficient or absent in public life and service. The most recent country to enforce forced unveilings in educational spaces is Azerbaijan, shortly after Austria and Kosovo.
However, discrimination, mockery, attempts to remove us from academic spaces, and aggressive attempts to unveil us are not recent. My Iranian great-grandmother lived under Kashf-e-Hijab (the Shah of Iran’s ban on all veils in public spaces to promote Western-style attire for both men and women). My grandmother once told me that her mother and grandmother like many women at the time would avoid going out altogether and if they had to they would go early mornings or late at night where there was less likely to be authorities on the street. If they were stopped by authorities they would say that they were tourists visiting from neighbouring Afghanistan, she said.
This forced unveiling mimicked soft power tactics to unveil Muslim women in Türkiye under the presidency of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, who viewed veiling or any traditionally Islamic clothing as backward. In his public speeches, he argued that traditional head coverings humiliated Turkish women and hindered national progress. Such beliefs and comments are not too different from verbal insults directed at veiled and visibly Muslim women today. During Kyrgyzstan’s campaign to pressure Muslim women to unveil, the government displayed billboards of women in niqabs, with the question, “My poor people, where are we going?”. In 2016, then-President Almasbek Atambayev repeatedly targeted veiled women in a press conference, also saying: “Women in mini skirts do not become suicide bombers”.
Tunisia, for instance, like India, Belgium and other countries, no longer implements its hijab ban in academic spaces, but discrimination and ridicule directed at veiled women continues. On one occasion, Tunisian actor Mohamed Kouka publicly remarked that “the hijab makes women inferior and less worthy” and that “when I come across a veiled woman, I wish to tear the headscarf up”. Hand in hand with their fantasies to unveil us, Mohamed Kouka has also made hand gestures showing himself ripping off an imaginary hijab on air and saying that the hijab “takes the value of women to the lowest”. When later asked why he said he would rip the hijab off, Kouka said it was “a joke” and refused to apologise.
Mimicking the harassment of women is not a “joke”, especially not to those who have experienced such physical assault. I was first threatened with this when I was in Year 8, just a little over a year after ‘Punish a Muslim Day’; a shirtless man waved his shirt at me, his upper body out of his car window, as he shouted: “I’m going to pull your hijab off.” Assault follows such threats. At age ten, my mother wrote in her diary (pictured): “Two young boys passed me, and from the back they pulled my scarf and laughed. I became very upset, but I did not turn back to look at them.” Thirty years later, when I found this page in a storage box in the garage, I asked my mother if she remembered, and she responded yes, before revealing that, even as an adult, she does not like going to funfairs because they remind her of moments like this in her childhood.
On another occasion, when I asked her whether she felt discriminated against at university for being a young mother, as I had to sometimes accompany her to university, she told me that she did not feel discriminated against or judged for that at all in front of her professors, but instead for wearing the hijab. “I always felt they look down on us, as if we are uneducated and ignorant, as if we are inferior and do not know anything.”
We are still thought of as lacking basic skills and education. At Oxford, after I had told someone where my grandmother had studied for her master’s, they said: “Wait, what? So she’s actually smart?” In her blog, British school teacher, by the name of Miss Moga wrote of one of her experiences of working in UK schools that: “When I attended the interview I was to first have a short meeting with the headteacher to be welcomed to the school and have a little tour, the initial moment she laid her eyes on me, she looked surprised and grasped her necklace and turned to her assistant and whispered (quite loudly!), “I thought she was the most educated candidate?!”,”.
Strangers on the street have asked me, “can you speak English?” before they stop me to ask something. ‘Perhaps you could argue that they have asked in good faith’, but what about the strangers that have stopped me on the street to say “you are not welcome here”, “aren’t you hot?” and even during my year abroad, “this is Armenia, you do not need to wear your… your bandana” and “you are in Armenia, you should respect our laws”. What about strangers who threw newspapers at my cousin’s face on the tube, and received thanks from onlookers as a result? Living through this daily puts pressure on young girls growing up to unveil. As Journalist Mohamed Hassan wrote in his award-winning poem ‘The Muslim women who raised us’: “when us men hide in shirts and jeans, shaved jaws, and blue eyes, nobody asks us where we are going, why we are here, what we are trying to prove with our insistence to go to school, to get degrees…”
Forced unveiling in women’s sports is also commonplace. At a press conference, Tunisian runner Habiba Ghribi told a young hijab wearing runner to “choose between the hijab and running”, to which she later burst into tears. This also echoes France’s attitudes to hijab-wearing athletes, who are not permitted to partake in competitions unless they unveil. For myself, it was only after I came across ice skater Zahra Lari, who wears a hijab, that I started ice skating again. It reflects the profound impact that representation has, and the need for young Muslim girls to be exposed to veiled women in different roles. Forced unveiling, apart from causing great psychological distress, places a glass ceiling upon the potential and dreams of young veiled Muslim girls.
I spoke to Elif Feyza Dinc, an MPhil student reading Development Studies. She came to Oxford after graduating from Boğaziçi University, one of Türkiye’s most prestigious institutions. Though only a generation earlier, her mother “lived through every hardship that the 28 February decisions produced”. She is referring to Türkiye in 1997, when the so-called postmodern coup carried out by the secular military establishment set in motion a sweeping hijab ban across universities and public institutions. She tells me that twenty-nine years later, its effects still resonate among Muslim women in Türkiye, and in their social attitudes and sense of belonging in public space.
“The ban was enforced brutally”, and her mother was forced to leave the school where she had spent four years. She instead had to complete her education through an open high school. “The second blow,” she says, came at university gates after women wearing the hijab were barred from entering campuses and “told to remove it if they wished to receive the education they had already earned, having passed a national exam from an unequal starting point”.
Some universities set up what came to be known as Ikna odaları, or ‘persuasion rooms’, which were spaces of psychological pressure and isolation where veiled students were coerced to uncover their heads. Her mother was among those caught in the system: “She came from a small town, where people had fewer resources and fewer alternatives once these restrictions took hold. In the end, she was unable to enrol in her faculty.”
Eighteen years later, however, after the ban was lifted and after becoming a mother of three at the age of 36, Elif’s mother prepared once again for the national university entrance exam. She was admitted to the Department of History at Marmara University in Istanbul and graduated second in her cohort, yet she “still speaks of those years as the time her rights were taken from her, and of her degree as a way of fulfilling the dreams she held at 18”.
The legacy of 28 February lies not only in the coup’s decisions, but also in the everyday language now engraved in women’s social memory. Throughout our conversation, Elif had deliberately avoided the word ‘victimhood’. She told me that this is because “the language for describing the suffering imposed by a top-down secular authority has itself been shaped, and weaponised, by parts of secular society”. In Türkiye, for instance, the phrase ‘bitmedi mi mağduriyetiniz?’ (‘will your victimhood never end?’) is routinely used to silence anyone who speaks about the injustices of 28 February in public conversation.
“To this day, Muslim women in Türkiye face ridicule in everyday life whenever they speak about the hardships they have endured because of their socio-religious identity. The ban may have been lifted, but the right to name what happened is still contested,” Elif says.
As we study in Oxford, and as you read, young Muslim Azerbaijani schoolgirls are having school gates closed on them and are sitting on the school steps studying in isolation. The international community of women’s rights activists have failed to protect them and stand up for their right to an education. Malala Yousafzai is among Oxford’s most well-known alumni and has built her entire brand of activism around young girls’ access to an education, but her silence in recent weeks proves that advocacy for women’s rights, including the right to an education and a right over our bodies, does not extend to veiled Muslim girls across the world, and most recently, distressed Azerbaijani schoolgirls.
When I reported on Oxford’s scholarship for Afghan women, who have been denied an education since the Taliban returned to power, it was painful to know that Oxford has not set up a similar programme for Azerbaijani girls. One could be quick to tell me that perhaps they are considering it and that these things take time and planning. But on the contrary, out of 193 UN recognised countries, Iran is the only one that has not hesitated to offer Azerbaijani girls a sanctuary and access to the education that they are being denied in their own country.
I ask all readers to reflect on what it means to deny a veiled girl an education, how little care one must have for that girl’s progress, place in society and livelihood. How these laws serve to further perpetuate the stereotypes of being uneducated, not thinking for ourselves when we veil, or being silent and absent.
As school gates slam in the face of young veiled girls and veiled teachers are being dismissed from their jobs when these bans are implemented, I ask all to reflect on the danger that not having a veiled teacher can have on pupils; when they are not taught or learning from a veiled woman. When the educated person standing in front of them in the classroom is never a veiled woman.
Even in countries where the hijab is not formally banned, women are discriminated against into unveiling. US school teacher Hind Haddad wrote of her experience of her first day at work: “When I arrived, the principal saw me and immediately frowned once she saw my appearance and the hijab on my head. She then informed me that it would be my first and last day at the school before I left to go to my classroom”. British schoolteacher, Miss Moga also says students looked at her “like I was some kind of alien or make-believe creature and I was instantly bombarded with questions such as: “Why do you dress like that?” and “Are you hot under there?”,” On another occasion, when a senior member of staff witnessed the Islamaphobic comments she was receiving from students, she told her, ”I can understand why they do not respect you” and, “the way you are dressed is hindering their learning.”
I reflect on my own experience as a veiled student in Oxford. As a fresher, I was hyper-conscious to not make mistakes in front of my peers or ask obvious questions during lectures because I knew that any scrutiny, especially with regard to intelligence or competence, would not just be directed at me as an individual, but would extend to people’s image of visibly Muslim women. When I expressed my exhaustion and frustration at this to someone during first year, they justified the prejudice. They said that I cannot expect anyone to consider me intelligent regardless of whether I have made it to the same competitive university as them or sitting in the same lecture hall as them, “because so long as you continue to wear the hijab, people will think that you lack critical thinking”.
Despite such force, pressure, and effort to unveil us, especially in academic spaces, our hijab will always be a reminder that Muslim women not only belong but thrive in these spaces. We have much more stamina and strength than to remove our veils in the face of soft power tactics, pervasive stereotypes, or even such bans and hard power tactics to eradicate our hijab. We are fully aware that our presence and veil irritate many who cannot stand to see us progress, but they will never make us compromise on our values, chip away at our identity, nor separate this hijab from our education. The two go hand in hand. Indeed, the world’s oldest university, two centuries older than Oxford, was founded by none other than a Muslim woman: Fatima al-Fihriya.
I wear my hijab in Oxford because girls younger than me across the world are denied an education because of this; my hijab is my way of resisting, of asserting our identity in an environment where our presence is unjustly limited. And because, as one social media user put it: “Those who fear a little girl’s headscarf also fear her pen.”
Lord Mendoza, Provost of Oriel College, confirmed that Nathan Cofnas’ event at Oriel will go ahead at today’s Extraordinary SU Conference of Common Rooms (CCR).
At the meeting, JCR and MCR representatives questioned Mendoza, alongside the Proctors’ Office Clerk Gillain Hamnett and the University of Oxford’s Chief Diversity Officer Tim Soutphommasane. Speaking on Oriel’s involvement in the event, Mendoza stated: “we want to live up to our statutory duty to protect free speech – free speech for the event and those to protest it.”
Mendoza also confirmed that the location of the event in Oriel has been changed to protect students.
Representatives from JCRs and MCRs as well as the SU representatives also debated a motion proposed by St Catherine’s College’s MCR president Xiangyue Wang, entitled: “No Hate Speech at Oxford”.
The proposed motion calls for a statement to be issued by the SU, pending voting from college representatives which is due to end tomorrow.
Further proposals include mandating the SU to spend £1,000 on diversity initiatives this term, for SU officers to ask the University’s proctors to attend the event in case of speech violating the 2010 Equality Act, and to support an independent review of the risk assessment and approval process for the event.
In the Q&A, students raised concerns that the content of Cofnas’s talk would not be lawful and could amount to harassment. The Ghent University academic is controversial for his role in publicising plagiarism allegations into Professor Jason Arday this July. Arday, who denied these allegations, resigned from Cambridge following media scrutiny and was later found dead.
The proposed motion notes that Nathan Cofnas is a self-described “race realist” who has previously said that without DEI (Diversity Equity and Inclusion), the number of black professors at Harvard would “approach 0%”.
One student asked whether the University considered race science and Eugenics an incitement to racial hatred. Soutphommasane responded by highlighting the University’s need to take students “in good faith” regarding the content of the events they plan to hold. Cofnas’s talk is publicised as a talk on whether DEI is “undermining higher education”.
Soutphommasane said: “I can tell you, as Chief Diversity Officer, these are questions I deal with every day. Having a debate with DEI is something that is not off limits for debate. I have to engage in these debates every day as a part of my job.”
A representative from St Antony’s College responded saying “it seems disingenuous to give [the speaker] the most generous benefit of the doubt given the broad range of things that could be said under the title [of the debate].”
Mendoza acknowledged the public outcry to cancel the event from students and staff across Oxford, saying “we don’t particularly want what, at best you might call a ‘controversial lecture’ But free speech guidance is clear. However enraged you might feel, however much you might feel something will damage the reputation of the institution.” He confirmed that the College has consulted lawyers who unanimously maintain that “the event must go ahead”.
The speakers continually highlighted the duties placed on the University by the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023. Following the implementation of the Act last year, both the University and Oriel have updated their Codes of Practice on freedom of speech to reflect the stronger legislative duty to protect lawful speech.
Under the Act, Universities and their constituent institutions, such as Oxford colleges, can be reported to a new Office for Students complaints scheme if they fail to protect the freedom of speech rights of visiting speakers and staff. The complaints scheme has the power to issue fines and mandate compensation to those affected.
Oriel’s new Code states that freedom of speech must be “robustly protected” and that cancellation of events is “undesirable and should be exceptional”. The code accepts that this means students will be “confronted with views that some find shocking, disturbing or offensive”. Mendoza also said that the code will likely be reviewed after the event, but that the policy is unlikely to change.
“This is a very serious moment for Oxford and its colleges,” Mendoza said. “This is not something we looked to take on, but we are fulfilling our duty. We are pleased to be an organisation that wants to protect freedom of speech.” He also noted Oriel’s strong support for DEI initiatives and its outreach work.
Hamnett confirmed that the Proctors are conducting an ongoing risk assessment to ensure the safety of students at the event. She said that society events are not approved in advance by Proctors and can only be cancelled by them pending a risk assessment assessing whether it is “safe and lawful”.
A representative from Nuffield College asked how the event could be approved if the assessment is still live. Hamnett said that the current situation is ongoing and “dynamic”, reassuring that there will be a cut-off period but “the decision, at the moment, is that nothing has come to light that would mean the event would be cancelled”.
St Catz MCR’s proposed No Hate Speech motion calls for the presence of the University’s Proctors or another independent supervisor at the event to monitor the event for speech potentially violating the 2010 Equality Act. Hamnett confirmed that the Proctor’s security officers, commonly referred to as “bulldogs”, would be at the event.
The CCR President, Roxana Rusu, explained that involving an independent body to supervise is “really crucial” and “something that we are really pushing for”.
Student representatives raised concerns about the Proctors’ role in the event, with one stating that “mitigations don’t make an event safe” and it is “disingenuous to say that this event is safe because the proctors are getting involved”.
Rusu explained that the Extraordinary CCR was called to ensure that measures decided at the meeting could be implemented as quickly as possible. “While we can only work with the structures we have previously,” she said “we really want to change them for the future, for the better”.
Oxford’s Reform society has previously defended the invitation on social media, noting: “since we are a student society registered with Oxford University, constituent colleges of the University are under a legal obligation to host events like ours by virtue of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023”. The statement goes on to say “Reform society is committed to hosting Nathan Cofnas, and allowing attendees at the event to engage in respectful dialogue with the same.”
The Free Speech Union has encouraged members to send emails congratulating Mendoza and Oriel for “standing firm” and for its “excellent” code of practice on free speech.
Common Room Presidents will be voting on the motion in the next 24 hours. If the motion is passed, a statement is expected to be issued tomorrow.