Protests start outside Oriel College ahead of Nathan Cofnas event: Live updates

Reporting by Mair Andrews, Stanley Arlidge, Oskar Doepke, Emma Heagney, Orla McMahon, and Freiderikos Vassos.

Additional reporting by Gavriella Epstein-Lightman and Madison Garrett.

Update: 21:00

Cherwell has ended its live coverage.

Update 20:45

Cherwell understands that police are informing protestors that Cofnas has left the building. Onlookers told Cherwell that he exited through a tunnel on King Edward’s Street.

Students in Magpie Lane accommodation are leaning over the walls and playing Bella Ciao for the barricading  protesters.

Oriel Square has now been cleared of demonstrators. Cherwell understands that students in Oriel are yet to be allowed out of the College. 

Update: 20:30

Concluding the Q&A, Cofnas said: “What I advocate is simply exposing the lie that underlies the ideology of modern day leftism, and making it impossible for DEI.”

Cherwell understands that the police have run out of Oriel College towards the High Street, and that Cofnas has now also left Oriel.

The President of Reform society has declined to comment.

The second Oriel JCR protest is expected to start shortly. One Oriel student told Cherwell that they disagree with earlier characterisations of the JCR’s response as “virtue-signalling”. The student, echoed by others, said: “The JCR and especially the executive committee have done everything in their power to make sure our views are listened to and actioned upon as much as they could.”

Update: 19:45

In the talk, Cofnas said that he argues “that the anti-hereditarian hypothesis in pseudoscience in the Lakatos sense”. He added, “just in terms of overall brain size, there are substantial differences, with Africans having the smallest and East Asians having the largest”. Cofnas then claimed that this aligned with IQ trends. “They can scream all they want, they can throw stuff at us, but that’s how it is”.

“What DEI means is that we hire Jason Arday and demand that you say he is a genius, and if you don’t, we flood you with death threats and stop people from coming to your talks.”

Police have now secured Oriel’s main entrance, pushing protesters off. Protesters still have the Oriel side entrance on Magpie Lane barricaded. At least five police vans are outside Oriel, and 17 officers have entered the college. Montgomery Toms has been escorted down Merton Street by the police.

In the Q&A portion of the event, the first question was asked by a journalist from The Guardian: “Would you like to apologise to Jason Arday’s family?”

Cofnas replied: “The implication is that I’ve done something wrong by pointing out corruption by a powerful public figure who sought power and fame. The implication is that we shouldn’t criticise public figures. Something bad happened, so therefore we shouldn’t talk about it. Is that what your point is? [Cambridge administrators] knew he was a fraud in 2023. They knew for three years. They chose to shut people down and intimidate people.”

Update: 19:30

Inside the talk, Cofnas stated: “The heritability of IQ is high. This is not a controversial fact.”

Outside, protesters are chanting: “Racist in a box.” At least seven have climbed over a wall into Oriel.

Cofnas then said: “Racism has fallen in the past few decades, and yet the IQ gap has remained constant for decades.”

Cherwell understands that protesters are now gathered near most of Oriel’s student accommodation.

Several police cars and an ambulance have also just arrived at Oriel Square. Over 15 officers are trying to get through the protesters, who are shouting “shame on you” at the police. Protesters are now barricading themselves in and the police out. Cherwell understands that the protesters are throwing the barricades back into the crowd and onto the police, who are joined by Montgomery Tom.

According to a student inside the talk, the Reform society president has asked Cofnas to wrap up in the next five to ten minutes. Cherwell understands that Cofnas is now discussing a constructive argument for race realism.

Update: 19:15

The President of Oxford Vegan Society, Freddie Nelson, told Cherwell: “He [Nathan Cofnas] can think whatever he wants, and no one’s going to stop him from saying things in the street. But Oriel College have a duty not to platform people who cause danger and hate toward their students, and that includes people of colour.” 

A representative for the Socialist Workers’ Party told Cherwell the protest is about “stopping fascism, stopping the far-right”, and that the protest will continue until “they stop hosting racists”. 

According to a student inside the talk, the protesters can be heard very loudly, with many members of the crowd looking towards the windows. Cofnas, now using a microphone, has said that there “is no scientific consensus on racial equality”.

Cofnas also stated: “If Cofnas’ nose is big, that doesn’t tell you that he’s Jewish. But if I tell you he has a big nose, and he has curly hair, and he’s from New York, then the probability goes up.”

Protesters have now returned to Oriel Square. On adjacent Oriel Street, they are banging on the college’s doors. One security guard stands between the protest and the entrance. Cherwell understands that several people are trying to scale Oriel’s walls, and that four people have made it over.

Update: 19:00

Oriel students can no longer enter through the main entrances. An email sent by Oriel’s JCR President says “students are advised to only enter/exist if strictly necessary”, with one side entrance still open to students. According to the email, Merton College’s porters’ lodge has agreed to shelter Oriel students until the protesters clear. 

An Oriel student told Cherwell that the JCR “have done what is within their power” regarding the protest inside Oriel. Another told Cherwell the JCR “has done a good job at keeping us safe”, although another critiqued that the student body does not have “much power”. 

According to a student inside the talk, Cofnas said he believes DEI is the “ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously”. Explaining what the “equality thesis” entails, he describes it as the belief that “everyone has the same potential”.

He then said that “none of them will publicly admit that [Jason Arday’s work] is a plagiarised text”. He added: “All of the evidence is on the hereditarian side.”

Cofnas also said John Locke originated the claim that people would be different if they were born elsewhere. He says: “It is not a coincidence that the father of liberalism was also the father of blank-slateism”, and later added that the supporters of the “equality thesis” do not have scientific evidence to claim that people are naturally equal. Cofnas also condemned the Nazis as anti-scientific and stated that it is “against scientific consensus” to claim that “there is no such thing as race and that all races are the same”.

Cofnas then described the protesters as “a mob trying to murder us just for talking about this stuff”.

Update: 18:45

Cherwell understand the Cofnas event has begun. Cofnas has introduced himself to attendees and said that “DEI is an ideology that is built on a lie”, according to a student inside the event.

Another student who wanted to attend Nathan Cofnas’ talk told Cherwell that Cofnas was “largely justified in publishing the obvious fraud on Jason Arday’s case”, and that “the affair wouldn’t have become so big if Jason Arday hadn’t threatened many journalists from mainstream newspapers with a police investigation”. 

The student continued: “I don’t get what these protests are helping or what they are for. Sure, people feel virtuous acting like animals, showing how strong they are, occupying a small street in a city, but no one is going to come to this and say, ‘oh, I was a raging fascist, but look at this, there are protesters blocking me from attending an event, I guess I am going to read Marx or something.’”

The student added that protesters “shouldn’t be allowed to block private property”, and that they are not sure “why that is legal”. The student was unable to enter the building for the event at the time of publication. 

Joylon Maugham of The Good Law Project spoke at the protest in Oriel Square. He said that “disabled, trans people, and immigrants are their targets. We resist together.” He also criticised the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act of 2023, saying that it has become “very hard for universities to stop the far right coming to your place of study and work”.

Referencing the American Declaration of Independence, he then stated: “Some truths are self-evident. Black students at Oxford deserve better. Black academics at Oxford deserve better.”

Cherwell understands that Montgomery Toms, an influencer closely affiliated with Restore Britain, is also near Oriel.

Update: 18:30

Oxford Resists is chanting “I believe that we will win”, referring to “this is not the end”, as Cofnas might return for another event. 

The national organiser of Black Lives Matter UK told Cherwell that the organisation is attending the protest to support the students who have asked them to be there. “Oxford University has always been a racist institution,” he says. “Students are disgusted that [Nathan Cofnas] gets to do a victory lap at Oxford University.”

Cherwell understands that Edward Dutton, a pseudoscientific “race scientist”, is also inside the event. Dutton, who posts on YouTube as “Jolly Heretic”, was removed from his post at the University of Oulu, Finland, after he plagiarised a student’s dissertation. He sits on the advisory board of Mankind Quarterly, a pseudoscientific journal, and is reported to be employed by the Human Diversity Foundation, an organisation promoting race science. 

Cherwell understands the event is about to start, although only 26 people are in attendance, including one Oriel welfare representative.

Update: 18:15

Cherwell understands that Cofnas’ talk has been delayed after protesters blocked entrances. According to a student inside the room, only 25 people are in attendance at the moment. 

An anonymous student told Cherwell: “When it comes to free speech, we kind of disagree on so many things, but we can never disagree on the value and the dignity of Black lives. That’s why I’m here.” Another student, with a background in genetics, adds: “Whatever he says is not backed by science. It’s pure racism. I really wish the genetics community would spread [this message].”

A parent of an Oxford student told Cherwell that “free speech has been put above the safety of Black students, at Oxford and elsewhere”.

When asked how the Cofnas talk makes her feel, another student said: “Like we are back in the 1930s.”

An Oxford City Green Councillor told Cherwell: “We can no longer allow Black people to be pushed into ever smaller spaces of safety.”

Update: 18:00

The Oxford student who organised a petition signed by over 32,000 people against tonight’s event has told the crowd that the Reform society has “wasted the platform they think they have”. He also condemned the University’s senior leadership, who have not spoken out against the event in their personal capacity. “This University means nothing if it is not willing to turn and say this is not welcome in our time. Tonight, Nathan, I say this to you: you are not worthy of our time.”

A lecturer at Oxford and a member of Oxford UCU, the bargaining representative, also spoke to the crowd: “We, the University workers, want no part of this racist nonsense.”

A student who attended a protest inside Oriel told Cherwell: “They are not doing enough… the JCR has neutered it.” The student added: “The student body wants to block this from happening. No one approves of it.”

“The JCR obviously opposes it and has to work with the college [Oriel] to some extent, but I think it has fallen short of representing the student body’s disgust at his speech. The protest is ineffective… it’s kind of virtue-signalling.” 

The student continued: “The University has really failed Oriel as a college and the entire community by allowing this event to happen.”

Cherwell understands that internal gates prevent Oriel students from accessing the areas attendees of Cofnas’ talk will use. The student also added that Oriel’s planned celebration during the event is just a “pizza party” and a “ridiculous waste of time and money”.

Update: 17:45

Cherwell understands that Corpus Christi College, Christ Church, and Merton College have closed their Merton Street entrances due to the protests. Corpus Christi has also stationed a security guard outside of the college.

Misan Harriman, one of the most widely-shared photographers of the Black Lives Matter movement, also spoke to the crowd. 

Around 75 protesters have gathered inside Oriel. Nathan Cofnas has not yet arrived, but protesters chanted “c*nt” at Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, the president of Oxford’s Reform society and organiser of the talk. Protesters inside Oriel can also be heard from Oriel Square, and have allegedly chanted “DEI makes us better”, “get Nathan Cofnas out of here”, and “is your mother proud of you?”

Signs underneath Oriel’s Rhodes statue read: “f*ck you Oriel”, “700 years of being sh*t”, “Rhodes must fall”, “free speech my a**”, and “save the UPP”.

Update: 17:30

Protesters outside the event have begun to chant: “Oxford University, you will always be stained with shame”, and “Nathan, you’re a wasteman. We all hate your guts. You think your pale complexion makes you better than us.”

Weyman Bennett, the joint convenor of Stand Up To Racism, told Cherwell that the speaker event “tells Black people that they are not welcome here”.

Cherwell understands that entrances to Oriel Square are now being blocked off. 

The right-wing YouTuber Young Bob, who frequently sets up debating stalls in university towns and campuses, has been followed through the middle of the protest, with people chanting “fascist scum off our streets”. Earlier in the day, he had set up a stall on Cornmarket Street with a large banner reading “DEI Murdered Jason Arday”.

The national organiser for Stand Up To Racism, Samira Ali, has given a speech, stating that the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society is “a danger to Black students and diversity on campus”. After reminding the protesters that they are there to remember Professor Jason Arday, “who should be [there]”, she added: “We are here to shut down that meeting. Reform society, we are coming for you, and we will shut you down too.” Protesters then began to chant: “Shut it down.”

Background

Nathan Cofnas, a self-described “race-realist”, will speak at Oriel College at 6.00pm today at an event titled “Does DEI undermine higher education?”, organised by the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS). Protests are expected ahead of the event, starting at 5.00pm, following a petition by Oxford Students’ Coalition Against Racism, which has received over 32,000 signatures by the time of publication.

Oriel has stated it is obligated to host the event under the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, even as Oriel’s JCR, MCR, and SCR have condemned Cofnas’ views. Cherwell has written a summary article covering the background to the event, the reaction from across the University, and the security arrangements in place ahead of the expected protest.

Check out our other content

Most Popular Articles